BionicBoy554 wrote:

Could I make a forum topic about a studio on Scratch?

superbuddy2 wrote:

I want to make a thread discussing who thinks what phones are the best.

Is this permitted? I thought it would be something beyond Scratch, but not necessarily reading or playing.

M1mikyu wrote:

I think the way the Pokemon Topic closure was handled was taken too far and making it so no current members can make a new one seems to be a bit extreme for an issue caused by only a handful of people and not the entire topic. I'd like to possibly discuss an alternate solution that hopefully everyone (or almost everyone) can agree is better so that we can have the Pokemon topic going again


also cool I just noticed this page is the 4444th topic on this forum section.. cool

Tophatted- wrote:

(#263)

superbuddy2 wrote:

I want to make a thread discussing who thinks what phones are the best.

Is this permitted? I thought it would be something beyond Scratch, but not necessarily reading or playing.

I think that would be allowed, although if it gets too heated it will most likely be closed.

M1mikyu wrote:

I think the way the Pokemon Topic closure was handled was taken too far and making it so no current members can make a new one seems to be a bit extreme for an issue caused by only a handful of people and not the entire topic. I'd like to possibly discuss an alternate solution that hopefully everyone (or almost everyone) can agree is better so that we can have the Pokemon topic going again


also cool I just noticed this page is the 4444th topic on this forum section.. cool

I personally agree although I might be biased as one of the old members. There really were only 3 (mostly 2) people who contributed to the closure. Most of us didn't argue much, and when we did, it was more civil. It's up to the scratch team to decide, however. (I am a bit annoyed about the fact we can't make the first post more like the old topics, we don't even have to call it topic 11, but the idea that we can't tell people about what Pokemon is and its recent game releases is a bit odd to me.)

M1mikyu wrote:

I think the way the Pokemon Topic closure was handled was taken too far and making it so no current members can make a new one seems to be a bit extreme for an issue caused by only a handful of people and not the entire topic. I'd like to possibly discuss an alternate solution that hopefully everyone (or almost everyone) can agree is better so that we can have the Pokemon topic going again


also cool I just noticed this page is the 4444th topic on this forum section.. cool

Scratchbeginner5669 wrote:

BionicBoy554 wrote:

Could I make a forum topic about a studio on Scratch?

i think scratch studios are best for the Show and Tell forum, as scratch studios are not related to TIRaP. it could be considered offtopic posting. (i am not a forum helper and not in the forum helpers studio, im just trying to say something that can be helpful.)

anyways, back on topic.

Valkyrie79 wrote:

How do you post?

7salad3salad wrote:

I thought this was closed…

mythbusteranimator wrote:

How come we can't talk about current news stories?
I remember some of them being closed on the old forums.

octopuswinslow wrote:

Do you think it would be allowed to make a new Geoguessr topic because the old one has been inactive for almost a decade and has some outdated links?

Crispydogs101 wrote:

octopuswinslow wrote:

Do you think it would be allowed to make a new Geoguessr topic because the old one has been inactive for almost a decade and has some outdated links?

I'd say maybe not since you can just bump it. Is it closed?

octopuswinslow wrote:

Crispydogs101 wrote:

octopuswinslow wrote:

Do you think it would be allowed to make a new Geoguessr topic because the old one has been inactive for almost a decade and has some outdated links?

I'd say maybe not since you can just bump it. Is it closed?

no it is not i guess i will bump it

Crispydogs101 wrote:

How come the Pokemon topic got another chance for a topic but fictional crushes did not?

Jigglypuffcupidcute wrote:

is it ok if people post topics about 1 game? I want to make a topic about the game called Welcome to the Loud house (by 1 game, I don't mean all of a creator's games, I mean one of their games)