Discuss Scratch
- Discussion Forums
- » Suggestions
- » Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
- undeterminstic
-
1000+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
bump for the third trillionth time
- Gamer_Logan819
-
1000+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
IM UNFOLLOWING THIS DISCUSSION ITS KEEP FLOODING MY NOTIUFICATION BOX
- BringUpYourPost
-
500+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
it isn't even very active IM UNFOLLOWING THIS DISCUSSION ITS KEEP FLOODING MY NOTIUFICATION BOX
- Caramels_Secrets
-
100+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
Support! Even though GIFs are fun to use and stuff, I understand now why there is accessibility issues.
- Tris_das_Einhorn
-
100+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
no purple is very important crazy how scratch team will be like “buh BUH buh scwAtch NWEEED 2 b poipule cuz uf the uhh 2 peoPle who took 2 seconDs loNger strAining to reaD a bit off coloRr text bEfore figGuring out how to zoOm in” but allow people who have serious vision disorders to have seizures when looking at a studio thumbnail
The purple update was super important for accessibility! I also think that the ST should be thinking about other accessibility issues with the site at the moment and taking steps to fix them (especially since they've shown with the purple update that accessibility is something they consider important), hence this topic.
- undeterminstic
-
1000+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
oh wait I forgot the comma, I meant to say “no, purple is very important”no purple is very important crazy how scratch team will be like “buh BUH buh scwAtch NWEEED 2 b poipule cuz uf the uhh 2 peoPle who took 2 seconDs loNger strAining to reaD a bit off coloRr text bEfore figGuring out how to zoOm in” but allow people who have serious vision disorders to have seizures when looking at a studio thumbnail
The purple update was super important for accessibility! I also think that the ST should be thinking about other accessibility issues with the site at the moment and taking steps to fix them (especially since they've shown with the purple update that accessibility is something they consider important), hence this topic.
- Tris_das_Einhorn
-
100+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
oh wait I forgot the comma, I meant to say “no, purple is very important” -snip-
Ahhhhh it's a fine day for me to be completely unable to English, I understand now
Thanks for keeping bumping this topic too!
- Elijah999999
-
1000+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
You're right, that's another benefit from this suggestion. Support. This energy saver setting will help slower devices!
- Elijah999999
-
1000+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
Classic “Let's eat Grandma!” situation XD oh wait I forgot the comma, I meant to say “no, purple is very important”
- EDawg2011
-
1000+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
1. I don't support this at all. GIF pfps and thumbnails allow more expression, if you know what I mean. If they were permanently gone, it would remove part of Scratch letting you express yourself. Since it has been mentioned that the ST might not have the resources to implement this suggestion as originally described, I'm going to clarify that there are three workable solutions, any of which could solve the problem:
1. Animated files are permanently disabled on the Scratch website.
2. Animated files are temporarily disabled, until the ST gets enough funding/time/etc. to implement a toggle system.
3. There is a toggle which allows each user to choose whether they want to see animated files. (original idea) - if a user has the toggle off, they will only see the first frame of the animated file.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d69c/3d69ce4bb79237c07f554de5669f5a4469bf8544" alt=""
2. I support this slightly more. But I don't like it for the reason I mentioned in #1. Plus, it could take a long time to get enough “funding/time/etc”
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d69c/3d69ce4bb79237c07f554de5669f5a4469bf8544" alt=""
3. How is this a solution? I feel like this is just your suggestion, but worded in a more confusing way.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d69c/3d69ce4bb79237c07f554de5669f5a4469bf8544" alt=""
Anyways, HUGE support. Seizures are a serious health risk, and this suggestion would welcome more people with epilepsy to Scratch.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5fa4e/5fa4ef2417109f77b2223a7a3bf6e50acc473a74" alt=""
- EDawg2011
-
1000+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
so true crazy how scratch team will be like “We made Scratch purple because of the minority who struggle to read the text, but it isn't really bad for their health.” but allow people who have serious vision disorders to have seizures when looking at a studio thumbnail
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d69c/3d69ce4bb79237c07f554de5669f5a4469bf8544" alt=""
- Elijah999999
-
1000+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
How can you agree with that, but at the same time be so against the idea of temporarily disabling GIFs? Although I agree that the Scratch community is terrible about handling forced changes, but if Scratch survived the purple, it can survive this too, right?so true crazy how scratch team will be like “We made Scratch purple because of the minority who struggle to read the text, but it isn't really bad for their health.” but allow people who have serious vision disorders to have seizures when looking at a studio thumbnailno offense
- EDawg2011
-
1000+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
If GIFs aren't animated, you might miss some content from the pfp. For example, if a GIF pfp keeps switching between pitch black and a Scratch Cat every 5 seconds, you would be missing some context. Also, some people use GIFs to express themselves. How can you agree with that, but at the same time be so against the idea of temporarily disabling GIFs? Although I agree that the Scratch community is terrible about handling forced changes, but if Scratch survived the purple, it can survive this too, right?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d69c/3d69ce4bb79237c07f554de5669f5a4469bf8544" alt=""
- undeterminstic
-
1000+ posts
Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails
but the temp disable of gifs to add the toggle will be temporary. anyway if your gif requires context it isn't a very good pfp - me 2023If GIFs aren't animated, you might miss some content from the pfp. For example, if a GIF pfp keeps switching between pitch black and a Scratch Cat every 5 seconds, you would be missing some context. Also, some people use GIFs to express themselves. How can you agree with that, but at the same time be so against the idea of temporarily disabling GIFs? Although I agree that the Scratch community is terrible about handling forced changes, but if Scratch survived the purple, it can survive this too, right?
- Discussion Forums
- » Suggestions
-
» Accessibility Option for PFPs and Thumbnails