Liking/upvoting comments

kosjalp

Support

scratchcode1_2_3

kosjalp wrote:
(#1001)
Support

Please be more constructive and elaborate a little more, since the forums aren't a ballot box

nikky10000000

Ye i support cuz its annoying when you reply “i agree” or “cool” but instead you just like the comment lol.
Also if this gets added they should add a “top” section to the comment showing all the top comments.

:3 (bro i was so close to frog of the page)

Last edited by nikky10000000 (Nov. 30, 2024 17:34:21)

medians

Bringing this topic up.

glitcX

klomaster10 wrote:
This would be a cool idea, but it also pose some problems, like spamming comments with memes and jokes and other junk, just so they could get a ‘like’ or ‘upvote’.

The project/profile could delete them (necroquote, but constructive ig)

Boss_1s

bump

Crow_Boy08

Support! This would be cool.

Last edited by Crow_Boy08 (Dec. 28, 2024 18:47:38)

nikky10000000

MEGA BUMP

Cool_kid092

this could work like youtube. let me explain
in youtube there is a feature that when you like a comment, it goes up, kind of like a topic in the forums.
so if it gets a lot of likes, it would be the top comment
yes i support

Spaceandmoon1

Cool_kid092 wrote:
this could work like youtube. let me explain
in youtube there is a feature that when you like a comment, it goes up, kind of like a topic in the forums.
so if it gets a lot of likes, it would be the top comment
yes i support

That's not how comments work though. So assuming that's how comments work here, then sure.

HelloJelloPeople

Cool_kid092 wrote:
this could work like youtube. let me explain
in youtube there is a feature that when you like a comment, it goes up, kind of like a topic in the forums.
so if it gets a lot of likes, it would be the top comment
yes i support

I feel like this would bring the problem of like begging. Which can just as easily be reported for such actions. And almost all, if not all, other platforms have these people.

mingo-gag

Bump: Because of a dupe and support because it will remind like the yt like button on comments. and it's that will fit well for scratch

HelloJelloPeople

mingo-gag wrote:
Bump: Because of a dupe and support because it will remind like the yt like button on comments. and it's that will fit well for scratch

Also similar to YT: users should be able to heart comments on their projects and profiles, as well as pin a comment.

Voxalice

HelloJelloPeople wrote:
(#1014)
mingo-gag wrote:
Bump: Because of a dupe and support because it will remind like the yt like button on comments. and it's that will fit well for scratch
Also similar to YT: users should be able to heart comments on their projects and profiles, as well as pin a comment.

Check out https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/topic/353621/ and https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/topic/41402/.

Last edited by Voxalice (Jan. 18, 2025 01:12:23)

hotcrystal

Support! This could be used for a “yes” or “I agree” response.

Last edited by hotcrystal (Jan. 18, 2025 01:22:54)

moocatgeckoplus

Yea but you shouldn’t be able to like your own comment so this doesn’t turn into something like YouTube comments filled with “ I liked my own comment

” like I don’t want that but liking and disliking comments is good idea

kip23s

Bro then people would beg other people for likes and make up stuff like ‘'If you don’t like this comment you are cursed'' and little kids would fall for it

And now none of y'all are making actual posts all of you are just saying ‘'Bump’' ‘'No support’' and ‘'Support’'

Last edited by kip23s (Jan. 18, 2025 18:29:08)

scratchcode1_2_3

kip23s wrote:
(#1018)
Bro then people would beg other people for likes and make up stuff like ‘'If you don’t like this comment you are cursed'' and little kids would fall for it

that's already a problem with the chains that goes like

TYPE THIS TO 2139083592085239058 MILLION OTHER PEOPLE OR YOU'RE CURSED (don't blame me i didn't start it)

so just report it

HelloJelloPeople

Voxalice wrote:
Check out https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/topic/353621/ and https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/topic/41402/.

Thanks!

kip23s

scratchcode1_2_3 wrote:
kip23s wrote:
(#1018)
Bro then people would beg other people for likes and make up stuff like ‘'If you don’t like this comment you are cursed'' and little kids would fall for it
that's already a problem with the chains that goes like
TYPE THIS TO 2139083592085239058 MILLION OTHER PEOPLE OR YOU'RE CURSED (don't blame me i didn't start it)

so just report it

Then the suggestion will make more of these comments and make the Scratch Team's job harder and the point of Scratch is to learn and not like comments and all this stuff

Last edited by kip23s (Jan. 19, 2025 18:31:59)

Discuss Scratch