Discuss Scratch
- Discussion Forums
- » Suggestions
- » Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
- bugsyk2009
-
500+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
It is now completely impossible for anyone without an X account (i.e. the majority of the site's user base) to see any post on X on an account's profile page other than the one they have pinned.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fd3bd/fd3bd2510fe79135f0bfcc4b2e3e59b61fe2994c" alt=""
For most of Scratch right now, status updates are not accessible. I propose the use of Mastodon or another service federated via ActivityPub to post updates instead, as:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fd3bd/fd3bd2510fe79135f0bfcc4b2e3e59b61fe2994c" alt=""
For most of Scratch right now, status updates are not accessible. I propose the use of Mastodon or another service federated via ActivityPub to post updates instead, as:
- They are free and open source, which aligns with Scratch's philosophy
- They don't have this limitation of not being able to view posts without signing up
- Basilikos
-
1000+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
AND there's no potential for little ones to see inappropriate content… I think.
Because they host their own istance of Mastodon, is that how it works? It's not centralized so it has no links to potential adult content
Because they host their own istance of Mastodon, is that how it works? It's not centralized so it has no links to potential adult content
- bugsyk2009
-
500+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Yes, Scratch could do this but defederating (disconnecting your instance from the others) is highly discouraged in the Fediverse. AND there's no potential for little ones to see inappropriate content… I think.
Because they host their own istance of Mastodon, is that how it works? It's not centralized so it has no links to potential adult content
- ToastRoastBoast
-
500+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
theres nitter which allows anyone to view x posts even without an account
- bugsyk2009
-
500+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Still, it's impractical. I've used Nitter many a time but it's ridiculous to have to rely on something like it. The ST doesn't link to Nitter on their status page (which they are unlikely to do) and I don't think it's a good idea to continue supporting X anyways. theres nitter which allows anyone to view x posts even without an account
- k7e
-
1000+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
What's wrong with supporting X/Twitter?Still, it's impractical. I've used Nitter many a time but it's ridiculous to have to rely on something like it. The ST doesn't link to Nitter on their status page (which they are unlikely to do) and I don't think it's a good idea to continue supporting X anyways. theres nitter which allows anyone to view x posts even without an account
- ajskateboarder
-
1000+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Because Elon Musk sucks and there's clearly a better alternative which many people are moving to: MastodonWhat's wrong with supporting X/Twitter?Still, it's impractical. I've used Nitter many a time but it's ridiculous to have to rely on something like it. The ST doesn't link to Nitter on their status page (which they are unlikely to do) and I don't think it's a good idea to continue supporting X anyways. theres nitter which allows anyone to view x posts even without an account
Support for reasons in the OP
- colinmacc
-
1000+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Bluesky or Threads is probably a better option than Mastodon.
I agree X is a complete binfire now.
Edit: it’s amusing I can’t mention the old name of X in a discussion nowdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d236b/d236b950cdf04cde139ef9aec6bd83c0db13a7a4" alt=""
I agree X is a complete binfire now.
Edit: it’s amusing I can’t mention the old name of X in a discussion now
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d69c/3d69ce4bb79237c07f554de5669f5a4469bf8544" alt=""
Last edited by colinmacc (Dec. 3, 2023 00:21:32)
- Dyanoa
-
100+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Support for reasons in op
- ToastRoastBoast
-
500+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
you can also add cohost it combines x and tumblr Bluesky or Threads is probably a better option than Mastodon.
I agree X is a complete binfire now.
Edit: it’s amusing I can’t mention the old name of X in a discussion now
also you dont need an account for cohost and its free and open source
Last edited by ToastRoastBoast (Dec. 3, 2023 00:27:27)
- bugsyk2009
-
500+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
If I remember correctly, Bluesky is invite only and Threads you need an account to view at all. Bluesky or Threads is probably a better option than Mastodon.
I agree X is a complete binfire now.
Edit: it’s amusing I can’t mention the old name of X in a discussion now
Plus, both are mostly closed source.
- bugsyk2009
-
500+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Would be open to Cohost. Downside is that it's not ActivityPub compatibleyou can also add cohost it combines x and tumblr Bluesky or Threads is probably a better option than Mastodon.
I agree X is a complete binfire now.
Edit: it’s amusing I can’t mention the old name of X in a discussion now
also you dont need an account for cohost and its free and open source
Last edited by bugsyk2009 (Dec. 3, 2023 01:09:38)
- roofogato
-
1000+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Because Elon Musk sucks and there's clearly a better alternative which many people are moving to: MastodonWhat's wrong with supporting X/Twitter?Still, it's impractical. I've used Nitter many a time but it's ridiculous to have to rely on something like it. The ST doesn't link to Nitter on their status page (which they are unlikely to do) and I don't think it's a good idea to continue supporting X anyways. theres nitter which allows anyone to view x posts even without an account
Support for reasons in the OP
There's really no alternative to X (HATE that I have to call it that now, ew) I also hate Elon, but the site he's made really cannot be replaced
Anyways, no support, “”“X”“” is more widely known and easier to use. Besides, Mastodon became irrelevant 2 weeks after it opened
- EngineerRunner
-
1000+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
no, you can actually view threads w/o an accountIf I remember correctly, Bluesky is invite only and Threads you need an account to view at all. Bluesky or Threads is probably a better option than Mastodon.
I agree X is a complete binfire now.
Edit: it’s amusing I can’t mention the old name of X in a discussion now
Plus, both are mostly closed source.
- Basilikos
-
1000+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
^^ Because Elon Musk sucks
this
- bugsyk2009
-
500+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Easier to use when it's unviewable without an account? I don't think so. That was the main point I made. Most Scratch users cannot legally sign up for an X account, so they are missing out on important status updates.Because Elon Musk sucks and there's clearly a better alternative which many people are moving to: MastodonWhat's wrong with supporting X/Twitter?Still, it's impractical. I've used Nitter many a time but it's ridiculous to have to rely on something like it. The ST doesn't link to Nitter on their status page (which they are unlikely to do) and I don't think it's a good idea to continue supporting X anyways. theres nitter which allows anyone to view x posts even without an account
Support for reasons in the OP
There's really no alternative to X (HATE that I have to call it that now, ew) I also hate Elon, but the site he's made really cannot be replaced
Anyways, no support, “”“X”“” is more widely known and easier to use. Besides, Mastodon became irrelevant 2 weeks after it opened
Mastodon is far from irrelevant. It is still being widely used in the free and open source software community—i.e. who it was made for and exactly what Scratch's whole idea was built upon.
- roofogato
-
1000+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Easier to use when it's unviewable without an account? I don't think so. That was the main point I made. Most Scratch users cannot legally sign up for an X account, so they are missing out on important status updates.Because Elon Musk sucks and there's clearly a better alternative which many people are moving to: MastodonWhat's wrong with supporting X/Twitter?Still, it's impractical. I've used Nitter many a time but it's ridiculous to have to rely on something like it. The ST doesn't link to Nitter on their status page (which they are unlikely to do) and I don't think it's a good idea to continue supporting X anyways. theres nitter which allows anyone to view x posts even without an account
Support for reasons in the OP
There's really no alternative to X (HATE that I have to call it that now, ew) I also hate Elon, but the site he's made really cannot be replaced
Anyways, no support, “”“X”“” is more widely known and easier to use. Besides, Mastodon became irrelevant 2 weeks after it opened
Mastodon is far from irrelevant. It is still being widely used in the free and open source software community—i.e. who it was made for and exactly what Scratch's whole idea was built upon.
“far from irreverent” id severely beg to differ
- josueart
-
500+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Instead of messages/posts, what about uptime pages, like for example Uptime Kuma?
These are self-hostable and don't rely of human beings manually posting the status.
Anyways, support. X is awful.
These are self-hostable and don't rely of human beings manually posting the status.
Anyways, support. X is awful.
- 54387a
-
1000+ posts
Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status
Support because I want to know more about why part of Scratch is down without having to convince my parents to let me check. Also, the Scratch Team usually doesn't put it out in the front page.
- Discussion Forums
- » Suggestions
-
» Use Mastodon or similar over X for server status