romswarez wrote:

Gamer_Logan819 wrote:

Is just a planet they made up really fast

Why does it have to be super detailed? That would kind of go against the theme of the whole interface.

It doesn’t, this entire suggestion is about simple and cartoony planet sprites

https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/users/Banguila/
This is from her alt and they look cute, and this could be a good mockup

cs3868895 wrote:

https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/users/Banguila/
This is from her alt and they look cute, and this could be a good mockup

Those are perfect, yes

Gamer_Logan819 wrote:

cs3868895 wrote:

https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/users/Banguila/
This is from her alt and they look cute, and this could be a good mockup

Those are perfect, yes

K https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/projects/456873559/ this is the project this was on-

You could just find a planet sprite and edit the costume. You could also just backpack pictures of planets from other people's projects. Or download pictures from the internet. You can maybe even ask a Scratcher who is really good at art to do those pictures. So we don't actually need new sprites. Some people also use art software to create images that they then upload onto their projects.

Why do most people oppose new sprites being added to the sprite library? There's no reason why this suggestion shouldn't be supported.

Za-Chary wrote:

Why do most people oppose new sprites being added to the sprite library? There's no reason why this suggestion shouldn't be supported.

I think it's because of this: https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/topic/671875/?page=1#post-7079001

Za-Chary wrote:

Why do most people oppose new sprites being added to the sprite library? There's no reason why this suggestion shouldn't be supported.

Usually it's because of Paddle2see's post or WDMSF (aka why do most suggestions fail)

But really there circles so….

cs3868895 wrote:

medians wrote:

cs3868895 wrote:

Also

Saturn Alr exists? Nani?

Oh my god I thought I was getting bamboozled until I saw your post.

Ig only that survived where is planet 1-

The trick is Planet1 was never a thing.

medians wrote:

cs3868895 wrote:

medians wrote:

cs3868895 wrote:

Also

Saturn Alr exists? Nani?

Oh my god I thought I was getting bamboozled until I saw your post.

Ig only that survived where is planet 1-

The trick is Planet1 was never a thing.

Oh because of earth lol

cs3868895 wrote:

medians wrote:

cs3868895 wrote:

medians wrote:

cs3868895 wrote:

Also

Saturn Alr exists? Nani?

Oh my god I thought I was getting bamboozled until I saw your post.

Ig only that survived where is planet 1-

The trick is Planet1 was never a thing.

Oh because of earth lol

Yep!

Reposting this since everyone decided to ignore my post:

Paddle2See wrote:

Please stop with the sprite suggestions - it's getting tiresome.

original post

Scratch--TheCat wrote:

Reposting this since everyone decided to ignore my post:

Paddle2See wrote:

Please stop with the sprite suggestions - it's getting tiresome.

original post

Correct me if I am wrong, but I think that is referring to the “remove ___” posts.

Za-Chary wrote:

Why do most people oppose new sprites being added to the sprite library? There's no reason why this suggestion shouldn't be supported.

Yeah, my post even got a comment from Paddle2See saying he may try it, so stop thinking Paddle2See is against all sprite additions. BTW, here is my post- https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/topic/683232/ not trying to advertise or anything like that but if you can, post your opinion! No, this is not advertising as it is related. FULL ON SUPPORT 4 THIS!!!!

EpicTangerine wrote:

You could just find a planet sprite and edit the costume. You could also just backpack pictures of planets from other people's projects. Or download pictures from the internet. You can maybe even ask a Scratcher who is really good at art to do those pictures. So we don't actually need new sprites. Some people also use art software to create images that they then upload onto their projects.

I would rather not go through the trouble of using one of two planet sprites to edit, both of which are terrible to edit.

I’ve stated why I can’t just backpack them

I cant download from the internet because I want it cartoony and in vector and real images are hard to edit

I’d rather not go through the trouble of doing this

What?

cs3868895 wrote:

Gamer_Logan819 wrote:

cs3868895 wrote:

https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/users/Banguila/
This is from her alt and they look cute, and this could be a good mockup

Those are perfect, yes

K https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/projects/456873559/ this is the project this was on-

I think my post didn’t go through, but, to summarize, I tried to reply later saying, upon further inspection, these would not look great. Saturn is kind of inaccurate and Venus is completely off. The rest are alright.

Za-Chary wrote:

Why do most people oppose new sprites being added to the sprite library? There's no reason why this suggestion shouldn't be supported.

EXACTLY WHAT I WAS THINKING THANK YOU FOR SAYING THIS

'well, the 8 year olds can try and not you, so you're just going to be bad at making planets forever' is just the worst argument against adding a sprite (especially since the OP has tried to make a planet sprite). like at that point that's just mean and also even more unconstructive imo.

Deetwo_ wrote:

Za-Chary wrote:

Why do most people oppose new sprites being added to the sprite library? There's no reason why this suggestion shouldn't be supported.

EXACTLY WHAT I WAS THINKING THANK YOU FOR SAYING THIS

'well, the 8 year olds can try and not you, so you're just going to be bad at making planets forever' is just the worst argument against adding a sprite (especially since the OP has tried to make a planet sprite). like at that point that's just mean and also even more unconstructive imo.

I could have said the same thing, however all things considered we'll have to treat the sprite suggestions differently.

Bump

Bump