Za-Chary wrote:

Prince_Wolf1 wrote:

I Don’t think you can compare AFD features and guides.guides are meant to be stickied and we already have enough guides.

Before the guide moratorium was imposed, not all guides were stickied, and not all guides were meant to be stickied. They were just created — and often bumped — cluttering the forums.

Za-Chary wrote:

Prince_Wolf1 wrote:

I Don’t think you can compare AFD features and guides.guides are meant to be stickied and we already have enough guides.

Before the guide moratorium was imposed, not all guides were stickied, and not all guides were meant to be stickied. They were just created — and often bumped — cluttering the forums.

Scratchdev57 wrote:

Support, but it will need a lot of moderation.

Sliverus wrote:

Scratchdev57 wrote:

Support, but it will need a lot of moderation.

How so? I don't see how this will require much more moderation since we already have a moratorium similar to this (the moratorium on guide topics), and yet the Scratch Team seems to be handling that very well.

mumu245 wrote:

Are guides still disallowed (why most suggestions fail just got stickied)?

Paddle2See wrote:

It's a good creative outlet - and you never know when a Scratch Team member might be inspired by one of the suggestions. I'm okay with keeping them around.
View source

I'm going to say no support. Let's say you are a developer of a game and you need ideas but you decide you check the ideas when the game comes out instead of adding the ideas during the process. Would you rather accept ideas before or after?

Yeah, they used to be funny, but they took up space, (as you mentioned,) and people had differing opinions on what was “funny” and what wasn't. And one of the biggest reasons is that if the ST did implement they're suggestion, it'd only be for a day, and lots of people would already know about it.

ObesityOfTheOld wrote:

(#76)

-InsanityGames- wrote:

Anyways, I have a solution. The creation of a stickied April Fools' “megathread”, like those found in a certain social media app.

that doesn't keep specific discussion very tidy though, so I think that may cause more issues than it solves.

After going through this topic, I do believe that @dertermeter has solid analysis. However, my main worry about April fools topics on the forums is if one of them gets accepted, than word will spread from forumers what an april fools feature will be. This spread may eventually outbreak to the main site, where loads of the Scratch community know about the april fools suggestion, meaning it's not really a surprise.

serialnumber404 wrote:

(#8)
While this is a kinda good idea, the first reason should be removed as >>a lot of suggestions are not typically added by ST.<<

SonicFanX123_321 wrote:

serialnumber404 wrote:

(#8)
While this is a kinda good idea, the first reason should be removed as >>a lot of suggestions are not typically added by ST.<<

Project Save & Level Codes