Well put! You can hear some of these same themes in this very old sticky topic as well - worth a read!

I think a lot of suggestions also ask for way too much. The developers have a lot of things to do, and some posts suggest something that just isn't realistic for the developers to add. This is a non-profit company. Some suggestions have a scope way beyond what Scratch can reasonably add.

CoconutGator wrote:

I think a lot of suggestions also ask for way too much. The developers have a lot of things to do, and some posts suggest something that just isn't realistic for the developers to add. This is a non-profit company. Some suggestions have a scope way beyond what Scratch can reasonably add.

EXACTLY, and then sometimes people add even more to those suggestions. I think we should have less “fun features” suggestions, and more “educational” suggestions.

Elijah999999 wrote:

CoconutGator wrote:

I think a lot of suggestions also ask for way too much. The developers have a lot of things to do, and some posts suggest something that just isn't realistic for the developers to add. This is a non-profit company. Some suggestions have a scope way beyond what Scratch can reasonably add.

EXACTLY, and then sometimes people add even more to those suggestions. I think we should have less “fun features” suggestions, and more “educational” suggestions.

I agree, but we should have at least a little fun in the suggestion topics though!

Why did they close all power block topics? We have trigonometry but not exponents.

rdococ wrote:

Let's look at the two largest features added to Scratch since 1.4: clones and custom blocks.

Both added in Scratch 2.0. They can't even add a power block but they have trigonometry!

mumu245 wrote:

rdococ wrote:

Let's look at the two largest features added to Scratch since 1.4: clones and custom blocks.

Both added in Scratch 2.0. They can't even add a power block but they have trigonometry!

I believe that they mean that it was added to Scratch after 1.4.

mumu245 wrote:

Why did they close all power block topics? We have trigonometry but not exponents.

They were either duplicates or merged with a topic by a former community moderator.
Edit: This one:
https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/topic/2860/

rdococ wrote:

Scratch is designed to be incredibly simple; kids as young as 8 years old must be able to pick up Scratch on their own and express themselves with stories, animations and games, as well as understand each other's code well enough to use it in their own projects.

What if someone made a suggestion to the scratch team not related to coding, or creating projects, but a suggestion to make the website better overall? For example, a redesign, or even my own idea for a recommended section on the explore page?

-StickyCoder-

• 14
  games
• 
  animations
• 
  cool
• 
  funny
• 
  

Most recent animation: https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/projects/809514073
Most recent game: https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/projects/782378270

I work with @DarkMoxxie_004 and @ThePurpleMan424
We Are Mox Studios

Oh, that makes a lot of sense.

rdococ wrote:

They're a bit tough to understand for an 8 year old, but you don't have to grapple with the more advanced parts like custom block inputs until you're ready.

That's the thing. Also, I doubt an 8-year old would unserstand trigonometry.

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:

You sweet summer childs.

A) It's children, not “childs” B) If you're trying to mess with my head, well done, consider my head yours.

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:

C) What was that for?

Elijah999999 wrote:

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:

You sweet summer childs.

A) It's children, not “childs” B) If you're trying to mess with my head, well done, consider my head yours.

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:

C) What was that for?

They made a mistake — Don't mind those.

Elijah999999 wrote:

Ronaldexl wrote:

Hello what's going on?

What do you mean?

They’re wanting to know what’s going on in this topic.

Over most of these suggestions have good ideas, but also more cons or half of the cons than more pros, which means that it’s not a good fit for Scratch, but for other places.

I’d say that some of the ideas I came up in the past didn’t help as much, but now it’s easy to understand.

Yeah I suppose that's true I guess