Discuss Scratch

musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

This topic is a duplicate of this topic, but I was given permission by the OP of that topic to create a new one. Proof.

TLDR; There should be an area in the editor that shows the amount of blocks, sprites, costumes, and/or time spent in a project. This is meant to be a tool for the creator rather than a cool stat for the community, and would allow the creator to see some more statistics about their project.


Sprites

Description: This will count the amount of sprites currently in the project. Users viewing the project could go inside and see this stat.

Pros:
  • Will allow people to know how many sprites they have without having to count them all
  • Especially helpful with projects with a lot of sprites.


Cons:
  • Could cause people to brag or think they're project is better because it has more sprites.



Costumes

Description: This will count the amount of costumes currently in the project. Users viewing the project could go inside and see this stat.

Pros:
  • Will allow people to know how many costumes they have without having to count them all
  • Especially helpful for animators who work with a lot of costumes.


Cons:



Code Blocks (duplicate)

Description: This will count the amount of individual code blocks currently in the project. Users viewing the project could go inside and see this stat.

Pros:
  • Could allow people who want to put "Made with over X code blocks!" in their projects' description to be more accurate
  • Especially helpful for projects with multiple sprites where the workaround isn't a productive option.


Cons:
  • Workaround: Right click and see the number where it says, "Delete X blocks?"



Total Time

Description: This will count the amount of time spent in the editor of the project. Users viewing the project could go inside and see this stat.

Pros:
  • Would be a very helpful way for scratchers to moderate their time.
  • Would be a good way for scratchers to know how much time they actually spent on a project.
  • Would allow "This project took X hours to make!" in project descriptions to be much easier.
  • No workaround.


Cons:
  • Might cause people to purposely spend time on scratch just so they can say, "I spent X whole hours on this project!" when they spent much fewer on it.



Mockups (sorry if CubeUpload is blocked for you)


960times10_5is106044
Scratcher
500+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

A better mock-up for time:
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

960times10_5is106044 wrote:

A better mock-up for time:

The share and see project page button are there, so this wouldn’t work.
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

Bump
Conduit7
Scratcher
100+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

support, although i have one question

musicROCKS013 wrote:

Total Time

Description: This will count the amount of time spent in the editor of the project. Users viewing the project could go inside and see this stat.
this is a cool feature, but i have a question: what if you spend time in the editor, not changing anything? like, for example, let's say you were to backpack assets in a scratch project. or maybe you have the editor open while you're AFK. in these scenarios, you are spending time in the editor, but you're not actually working on the project. that would make the time spent working on the project inaccurate.
Quantum-Cat
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

I think it should be, as in the original suggestion, a button, as it is more of a tool that you would use in specific cases (perhaps the block counter should be left directly visible as a useful thing for code optimization) as I don’t imagine staring the time I spent that often or regularly counting costumes and sprites, because it doesn’t change very frequently.
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

Conduit7 wrote:

what if you spend time in the editor, not changing anything?
The count will still go up, because determining if someone is afk is a bit ambiguous.
yavuz61035
Scratcher
500+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

musicROCKS013 wrote:

Conduit7 wrote:

what if you spend time in the editor, not changing anything?
The count will still go up, because determining if someone is afk is a bit ambiguous.
what about no keys have been pressed in 1 minute/no changes has been made in 1 minute
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

bump
-Valtren-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

I support time, code blocks, and sprites, but not costumes since they're easily countable. just look at the number next to each costume name. shouldn't be too hard to go to the costumes tab and check the number of the last costume

sprites are also easily countable but if you have a lot of sprites you have to count them all manually
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

-Valtren- wrote:

I support time, code blocks, and sprites, but not costumes since they're easily countable. just look at the number next to each costume name.
I'm pretty sure this will be for all sprites, not just for one, so it would still be a good feature to have if you have a lot of sprites.
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

bump
Jbear_
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

I like this, this would make a Good QoL update, and I don’t think people would brag about how many sprites they have in a project
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

Jbear_ wrote:

and I don’t think people would brag about how many sprites they have in a project
Yeah, it was one of those things where I wanted to put something just to seem less biased.
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

yavuz61035 wrote:

what about no keys have been pressed in 1 minute/no changes has been made in 1 minute
Hmm… I could see a lot of workarounds for these. Like, before you go to sleep you could put a rock on one of your arrow keys after highlighting a section of a costume. Or even better, someone just makes a python bot to run up the time. I don’t think there should be anything like that because then people will try to exploit it or run up the time, and it wouldn’t really be fair for people who don’t do this.
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

Bump
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

bump
TheGlassPenguin
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

PROJECT SPEEDRUNNIN TIME


I don't really see how having how much time you've spent working on a project would be very useful, but that's just me. Block counters are something I'd like back (mainly for bragging rights on school projects)
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

TheGlassPenguin wrote:

I don't really see how having how much time you've spent working on a project would be very useful, but that's just me.
I think it would be a good way to manage your time better (woah, I've spent 5 hours on scratch! I should get off) or even help to let you know how long you've been working on something. Like, I've seen projects that will say in the description “This project took 5 hours to make,” and I think that would help those to be more accurate and just be a good way to get feedback on your project.

TheGlassPenguin wrote:

Block counters are something I'd like back (mainly for bragging rights on school projects)
Say what? Was this a feature before?

Also this could help teachers to be able to set limits like “50 blocks minimum” or something like that, to kind of force students to do something. Same could go for the time counter.
musicROCKS013
Scratcher
1000+ posts

[Sprite, Costumes, Code Blocks, Time Spent] Counter

bump

Powered by DjangoBB