Censoring shouldn't affect share dates

sharkode

Changing the share date can cause confusions to which project is original, which leads to false reports and more auto censoring, also, some mass reporters want a project to be taken down to cause confusion, if we keep the original share date, it might reduce the number of mass reporting

Edit: This includes both auto censor and legitimate censoring by ST, as it could also cause confusion and sometimes ST censor things by mistake

Last edited by sharkode (March 6, 2022 19:40:05)

JohannGomez2021

Support?

jackson49

Support. A good example of this is with the project Weekend

k0d3rrr

Support! I think a huge example of this is "Weekend", which now says it was shared on February 3rd, 2022 (or 3rd February, 2022).
Edit: I'm not the first person to mention Weekend…

Last edited by k0d3rrr (Feb. 6, 2022 06:34:54)

sharkode

k0d3rrr wrote:
Support! I think a huge example of this is "Weekend", which now says it was shared on February 3rd, 2022 (or 3rd February, 2022).
Edit: I'm not the first person to mention Weekend…

I actually made a similar suggestion earlier, if it was implemented this wouldn't have happened

jackson49

Actually, I think this might be a duplicate

Last edited by jackson49 (Feb. 6, 2022 16:30:50)

sharkode

jackson49 wrote:
Actually, I think this might be a duplicate

No, it's not

jackson49

sharkode wrote:
jackson49 wrote:
Actually, I think this might be a duplicate
No, it's not

You're right, this is about censoring, not unsharing. Sorry.

-Morni-

i support

vudeptrai090211

-Morni- wrote:
i support

please be constructive.
by the way, i support this idea because it wouldn't make confusion.

Last edited by vudeptrai090211 (Feb. 7, 2022 07:26:39)

sharkode

bump

Scratchfangs

-Morni- wrote:
i support

You should know better, don't you spam across posts to tell people to close their topics if it's answered, and tell people to tell why they support?

bobcat0701

support this would stop confusion over projects like weekend getting unshared

sharkode

bump

sharkode

Bump, this could end mass reporting

VeryFamus

This actually makes a lot of sense. The date shouldn't really be reset, as they were shared then. Should it change if the project was reshared if it wasn't taken down, or only if it was taken down? Should there be two different dates for “Originally Shared” and “Reshare Date”, the “Reshare Date” Only showing if it had been previously unshared?

sharkode

VeryFamus wrote:
This actually makes a lot of sense. The date shouldn't really be reset, as they were shared then. Should it change if the project was reshared if it wasn't taken down, or only if it was taken down? Should there be two different dates for “Originally Shared” and “Reshare Date”, the “Reshare Date” Only showing if it had been previously unshared?

Uhh, No… You made most of it up with your imagination

VeryFamus

sharkode wrote:
VeryFamus wrote:
This actually makes a lot of sense. The date shouldn't really be reset, as they were shared then. Should it change if the project was reshared if it wasn't taken down, or only if it was taken down? Should there be two different dates for “Originally Shared” and “Reshare Date”, the “Reshare Date” Only showing if it had been previously unshared?
Uhh, No… You made most of it up with your imagination

I'll take that as an answer to my question, that answer being ‘this topic does not include unsharing by the project owner.’, which honestly seems like it would make more sense than it would including that. Thanks for the clarification.

brillaoscoder

This is an amazing idea! An amazing game called blocky got taken down and I am so sad!

coderwe2

sharkode wrote:
Changing the share date can cause confusions to which project is original, which leads to false reports and more auto censoring, also, some mass reporters want a project to be taken down to cause confusion, if we keep the original share date, it might reduce the number of mass reporting

Edit: This includes both auto censor and legitimate censoring by ST, as it could also cause confusion and sometimes ST censor things by mistake

Very constructive suggestion! I think there should be a original day posted for every project so they know when it was posted and the should also show when it was reshared if it was reshared.

Discuss Scratch