Tell the user when their project is marked as NFE.

Rendangbike2

Support! If your project is NFE, you should know because it's your own project.

Last edited by Rendangbike2 (Feb. 14, 2021 14:28:47)

Chiroyce

Support! Because of the same

Rendangbike2 wrote:
Support! If your project is NFE, you should know because it's your own project.

dertermenter

Support. We should know why, then maybe we can fix it and make it not NFE

MrPenguin303

support

Rendangbike2

MrPenguin303 wrote:
support

why

GoogleInScratch

Support, It's your project and you should know if it is NFE.

Last edited by GoogleInScratch (Feb. 14, 2021 16:54:30)

the2000

GoogleInScratch wrote:
Support, it should be obvious why ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Then why don't you explain it? Please be constructive, statements like “for obvious reasons” and “for reasons given above” are unconstructive by definition.

Bacteria999

support, if a scratcher has an nfe project, he can remove the inappropriate parts and make it more appropriate for the community.

Tiger_Person

support

1Oaktree2

BUMP

Support, example below

example wrote:
This is Tim:
Tim made a project that he thinks is completely fine
A small group of people found his project scary
Scratch Team wrote:
We must mark this project as NFE so that people who think it is scary will be less likely to see it
And then he gets nominated to be put on the front page
Tim wrote:
Why isn't my project on the front page/as popular as it should be?
*Confusion and outrage among the Scratch Community*

But… here is the example if there was a notification

example 2 wrote:
Admin message wrote:
Your project has been marked as NFE, you will not recieve any punishment, but, incase {Insert group of people who would get scared here} see it, we can't put it on the front page
Tim understands.

Last edited by 1Oaktree2 (Feb. 16, 2021 17:04:15)

LilyHorse

Support

Futurebot5

LilyHorse wrote:
Support

Why?

fdreerf

I don't know what my stance was on this but I don't feel like looking for it.

For the vast majority of Scratchers, NFE cannot even be considered a punishment. Their projects have a near-zero chances of being on the front page and nobody was searching for them anyway. The only people this affects are well-known Scratchers who are going to get on the front page and get searched for.

However, those same users are more likely to get more reports for a scary thing than a less popular Scratcher's scary thing. Thus, it would make sense for the Scratch Team to straight-up remove the project instead of marking it as NFE. Plus, it seems like the Scratch Team doesn't even mark projects as NFE all too much as it's only for the projects in the crossroads between “complying with the CGs” and “not suitable for general audiences”.

Last edited by fdreerf (Feb. 17, 2021 00:51:03)

Rendangbike2

Bumpush

TheTrillion

The user should deserve should to know when their project is marked as NFE so they can remove the parts that made it marked as NFE. Say Bob made a really good project and it is front page quality. It is NFE though (animated thumbnail). So when John proposes it to be featured, Bob can’t have his project featured because it’s NFE. But if this feature existed…

Scratch Team wrote:
Hello! We have found out your project called Weekend has been marked as NFE. NFE is when a project is inappropriate, but is not too inappropriate enough to be removed. NFE projects barely come up in the search results and cannot be on the front page. Here is the reason your project got marked as NFE: Animated thumbnail.

Bob removes the animated thumbnail and the Scratch Team sends him this message:

Scratch Team wrote:
Hello! Your project Weekend has been unmarked as NFE since you removed the animated thumbnail. It can now come up more commonly in search results and can be on the front page.

Bobs good project can now be featured and more.

Last edited by TheTrillion (Feb. 23, 2022 04:34:18)

Maximouse

I don't think it makes sense to expect this to be implemented if even sharing websites that tell if a project is NFE is not allowed.

mybearworld

It wasn't intended to be public I think, so probably not going to be implemented

scienceexplorer1

Support!
Or users wonder why their project doesn't go front-paged

sonic__fan

Support!
If someone wants their project on front page, they may get questions as to why they aren't. This could help answer that question.

Scratchperson1000000

-TheFoundation- wrote:
Support

explain.

Discuss Scratch