Discuss Scratch

CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

Leekalo wrote:

Support. The suggestion isn't so helpful because you still have to scroll to find helpful comments. What's better is to make it so people can see the comments marked as helpful in a list. I also suggest helpful comments to be marked yellow.
added that to the OP
Prime689
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

amazon
Although this might highlight constructiveness, it might promote plural harassment by saying “Oh, this project is the worst” and nine people mark it “as helpful”. It can also trigger moderation issues, such as if the comment will be reported, but there's no way to track the people who marked it; a chronological index may solve this, but it may perplexing in terms of mass episodes conducting this scenario.
CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

Prime689 wrote:

amazon
Although this might highlight constructiveness, it might promote plural harassment by saying “Oh, this project is the worst” and nine people mark it “as helpful”. It can also trigger moderation issues, such as if the comment will be reported, but there's no way to track the people who marked it; a chronological index may solve this, but it may perplexing in terms of mass episodes conducting this scenario.
only the creator can mark them as helpful
Prime689
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

CoolLionMan wrote:

Prime689 wrote:

amazon
Although this might highlight constructiveness, it might promote plural harassment by saying “Oh, this project is the worst” and nine people mark it “as helpful”. It can also trigger moderation issues, such as if the comment will be reported, but there's no way to track the people who marked it; a chronological index may solve this, but it may perplexing in terms of mass episodes conducting this scenario.
only the creator can mark them as helpful
Oh, but how about studios?
CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

Prime689 wrote:

CoolLionMan wrote:

Prime689 wrote:

amazon
Although this might highlight constructiveness, it might promote plural harassment by saying “Oh, this project is the worst” and nine people mark it “as helpful”. It can also trigger moderation issues, such as if the comment will be reported, but there's no way to track the people who marked it; a chronological index may solve this, but it may perplexing in terms of mass episodes conducting this scenario.
only the creator can mark them as helpful
Oh, but how about studios?
I don't think it should be in studios because there's not as much point in it
dhfbei8987
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

Yup, support to the max. Marking things as helpful will help others realize what is and isn't constuctive.
CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

another bump and again ignoring fdreerf's advice

Last edited by CoolLionMan (March 12, 2021 03:37:50)

CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

CoolLionMan wrote:

another bump and again ignoring fdreerf's advice
CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

CoolLionMan wrote:

CoolLionMan wrote:

another bump and again ignoring fdreerf's advice
S E C O N D P A G E
CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

CoolLionMan wrote:

CoolLionMan wrote:

CoolLionMan wrote:

another bump and again ignoring fdreerf's advice
S E C O N D P A G E
CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

bump
CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

CoolLionMan wrote:

bump
CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

bump
CoolLionMan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

CoolLionMan wrote:

CoolLionMan wrote:

bump
Queer_Royalty
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

I'm sorry, but this is a duplicate.
chco123
Scratcher
95 posts

Mark comments as helpful

PkmnQ wrote:

Isn't this sort of like pinning?
yes yes it is
Harakou
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

Queer_Royalty wrote:

I'm sorry, but this is a duplicate.
I don't really see how? Someone suggesting this idea in the comment of a different suggestion does not make it a duplicate.
leahcimto
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

chco123 wrote:

PkmnQ wrote:

Isn't this sort of like pinning?
yes yes it is
no, no it is not. this is suggesting to make comments marked as helpful yellow, not pinning them to the top.
abstractcoder360
Scratcher
100+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

Queer_Royalty wrote:

I'm sorry, but this is a duplicate.
no this isn't. anyone can like comments, but only the creator of the project it was posted on can mark them as helpful.

Last edited by abstractcoder360 (Jan. 30, 2024 19:56:42)

ajskateboarder
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Mark comments as helpful

abstractcoder360 wrote:

Queer_Royalty wrote:

I'm sorry, but this is a duplicate.
no this isn't. anyone can like comments, but only the creator of the project it was posted on can mark them as helpful.
Bump?

Would marking a comment as helpful be similar to how creators heart a comment on YouTube? I guess that would be the only thing that makes sense, given the project creator is the only person marking comments as helpful

Powered by DjangoBB