Best block idea! Organise code [CODE SECTIONS]

theonlygusti

I would love to have the ability to sanction my code into different sections. This would make it so much easier to use, edit and debug my projects, and I'm sure others will feel the same way.

It would be brilliant if we could see a c-block that allows us to add this function, my concept looks like:

[name-of-section] ▼:: grey 

[name-of-section] ▲ {

} :: grey

The arrows let your code become collapsible chunks, so that extremely large scripts can suddenly become much easier to manage. You can use the text area to name your section whatever you want.

Also, these blocks shouldn't be in the block palette, as that might confuse new scratchers. I suggest distinguishing them from current blocks, maybe by rounding corners entirely, and having the as a right click option, like comments.

It would make projects so much nicer and easier to organise, which in turn makes projects easier to learn from.
Learning from other projects is one of the key concepts of Scratch!
This block will make that easier to accomplish.

You could turn a mess of stuff into something nice to view and debug,

when green flag clicked
[setup] ▲ {
set [xv v] to [0]
set [yv v] to [0]
goto x: (0) y: (-100) ::motion
show
} :: grey
[gameplay] ▼:: grey 
[gameover] ▲ {
play sound [deathnoise v] until done
} :: grey

As they contain collapsible sections, the above, by clicking on the arrow, could become:

when green flag clicked
[setup] ▲ {
set [xv v] to [0]
set [yv v] to [0]
goto x: (0) y: (-100) ::motion
show
} :: grey
[gameplay] ▲ {
repeat until <gameover ::operators boolean>
if <key [a v] pressed?> then
change [xv v] by [-1]
end
if <key [d v] pressed?> then
change [xv v] by [1]
end
if <key [w v] pressed?> then
change [yv v] by [1]
end
end
} :: grey
[gameover] ▼:: grey

Please let me know what you think of my idea. If you want to include the custom blocks in your post then, using scratch blocks plugin, it looks like

[comment] ▼ :: grey

[comment] ▼ :: grey

and

[comment] ▲ {

} :: grey

[comment] ▲ {

} :: grey

Last edited by theonlygusti (Aug. 31, 2016 21:00:27)

GyroscopeBill

It's cool. It's a lot neater than the comments we have at the moment.

AonymousGuy

Those aren't really comments…

theonlygusti

AonymousGuy wrote:
Those aren't really comments…

I know, I will re-title it if you can think of a name, it's just that this is the one I came up with.

djdolphin

Can't you just use comments to label the sections?

AonymousGuy

There is technically a workaround (put all the scripts in custom blocks) but I still think it would be useful.

Support.

Blueinkproductions

AonymousGuy wrote:
There is technically a workaround (put all the scripts in custom blocks) but I still think it would be useful.

Support.

Technically
Anyway, support.

Firedrake969

Technically a workaround, yeah, but I support.

(I think this is the first time I've supported a workaroundable thing

)

turkey3

I support, because attached comments can get messy. And the drop-downs can make code very clean,

Last edited by turkey3 (July 29, 2014 23:56:31)

theonlygusti

Some of you have said how there is technically a work-around, although there might be, it would still leave projects quite messy with all the

define section

just lying around.

epicsandwich123

support

theonlygusti

djdolphin wrote:
Can't you just use comments to label the sections?

Yes, but current Scratch comments are the ugliest things. This block would make everything neater. Even just a comment block would make everything neater.

Blaze349

turkey3 wrote:
I support, because attached comments can get messy. And the drop-downs can make code very clean,

Thepuzzlegame

Support

djdolphin

theonlygusti wrote:
djdolphin wrote:
Can't you just use comments to label the sections?
Yes, but current Scratch comments are the ugliest things. This block would make everything neater. Even just a comment block would make everything neater.

I'd prefer inline, multiline comments (like the old comment block) that could wrap around scripts, instead of a dedicated section block.

theonlygusti

Yes, that was actually my first idea. I do like the idea of collapsible c-blocks though, we could just multi-line the title section so that it can be used as a comment

theonlygusti

How about also re-adding the old comment block? That is neater than the current comments (if it was added, I would actually start using comments):
These new blocks could maybe have their own palette, called comments or organise, or something like that. They could also appear under the More Blocks palette.

comment > :: grey

comment v :: grey
[multi-lineable area] :: grey

section: [title] :: grey cstart

superninja109

support when I want to bugfix the game that I have a link to in my sig, It is like going through a jungle of scripts because some of the are even on top of each other.

Blueinkproductions

superninja109 wrote:
support when I want to bugfix the game that I have a link to in my sig, It is like going through a jungle of scripts because some of the are even on top of each other.

Right-click->clean up can help.

PH-zero

Yes! Support!

Discuss Scratch