Discuss Scratch

inom5962dojo
Scratcher
100+ posts

A private censor list.

asdfperson135 wrote:

glomeromycota wrote:

i honestly dont see the use for this, unless you are racist or have some phobia against certain people, there is really no use since both the forums and main site are pretty well moderated anyways
but they won't remove the words heck and hell, and some people hate heck and hell, and what if somebody says something like ****. It still goes through on the forums until the ST removes it. So during that limbo time, you have the shot of letting a third grader see the hard r or something.
That and trigger words.
inom5962dojo
Scratcher
100+ posts

A private censor list.

Elijah999999 wrote:

I like this idea, but I don't want to type in the words I don't want to see. Maybe there could be options, like “regular” “on” and “strict” and it could enable one by default depending on your age. I mean come on, we have first-graders on this platform!

The problem with that though is trigger words, they can't make a seperate list for that. Maybe have a friend type in the words for you if this gets implemented.
Elijah999999
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

inom5962dojo wrote:

Elijah999999 wrote:

I like this idea, but I don't want to type in the words I don't want to see. Maybe there could be options, like “regular” “on” and “strict” and it could enable one by default depending on your age. I mean come on, we have first-graders on this platform!
The problem with that though is trigger words, they can't make a seperate list for that. Maybe have a friend type in the words for you if this gets implemented.
I wasn't suggesting this would replace the current suggestion, I was just saying that it could be one of the options. I'm starting to lose hope in the way people view certain words.
Basilikos
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

asdfperson135 wrote:

Basilikos wrote:

Elijah999999 wrote:

Guys, this is just causing a huge argument. I see no way in which a toggleable feature would harm you.
I do not believe that it will harm me, I believe that it is a waste of time to implement.
all you have to do is literally duplicate the normal blacklist then let the user edit it. it really is not that hard.
And create the layout appositely for that with DIV and SPAN hell + React stuff, styling with CSS and Javascript and SQL stuff, create a completely new database, a very large one, to store the censored words ( which would just need more money to be spent… ) and then hope that somehow they will still be able to keep up with all the traffic.
Why do you think updates take so long?
Basilikos
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

asdfperson135 wrote:

Basilikos wrote:

This site's age demographic is not meant for six year olds, if they enter this website they may do so at their own risk with the knowledge that they're not meant to be here.
Read the guidelines one more time and come back

Scratch Community Guidelines wrote:

1.3 Scratch is open to children and adults of all ages, and we ask that you keep this in mind when using the Scratch services. When you use Scratch, you agree to abide by the Scratch Community Guidelines.
If you re-read that, it says that it's open to everyone. That still doesn't mean that it was meant for six year olds.
Go to scratch.mit.edu/about and check the section “Who uses Scratch” and it'll tell you it's meant for users from 8 to 16 years of age, even if it's open to everyone.
Crispydogs101
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

There is one thing. If heart was added in the custom blacklist. It may be easy to detect that they said the word that can be upsetting to some people.

Like if someone said “I got a heart by medians!” It would be
“I got a ***** by medians!” They would know that star is 4 letters so they would go with heart and that may upset them.
Elijah999999
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

Crispydogs101 wrote:

-snip-
I don't believe the word “heart” is very triggering for many people, and I doubt it would tell you the length of the word.
Dogs-are-amazing1
Scratcher
500+ posts

A private censor list.

Elijah999999 wrote:

Crispydogs101 wrote:

-snip-
I don't believe the word “heart” is very triggering for many people, and I doubt it would tell you the length of the word.
I think it was an example
inom5962dojo
Scratcher
100+ posts

A private censor list.

Elijah999999 wrote:

inom5962dojo wrote:

Elijah999999 wrote:

I like this idea, but I don't want to type in the words I don't want to see. Maybe there could be options, like “regular” “on” and “strict” and it could enable one by default depending on your age. I mean come on, we have first-graders on this platform!
The problem with that though is trigger words, they can't make a seperate list for that. Maybe have a friend type in the words for you if this gets implemented.
I wasn't suggesting this would replace the current suggestion, I was just saying that it could be one of the options. I'm starting to lose hope in the way people view certain words.
Ah, sorry. That is a good idea, now that I actually understand it.
Prince_Wolf1
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

Basilikos wrote:

lapisi wrote:

Basilikos wrote:

(#446)

asdfperson135 wrote:

Basilikos wrote:

officesuppliez wrote:

for those confused as to what would be censored, this would be useful for people who are triggered by certain subjects.
they could censor the words that upset them, ex: abuse, murder, death, etc

officesuppliez wrote:

for those confused as to what would be censored, this would be useful for people who are triggered by certain subjects.
they could censor the words that upset them, ex: abuse, murder, death, etc
Unless they've got a serious mental illness then they can probably get over it eventually.
so what if they do have one, do we just say deal with it?
Just, avoid places in which the trigger is often mentioned?
what if it's suddenly mentioned in a place where it isn't often mentioned?
Cope…
“Cope with your trauma flashbacks”
What if someone’s still in therapy
asdfperson135
Scratcher
500+ posts

A private censor list.

Basilikos wrote:

lapisi wrote:

Basilikos wrote:

(#446)

asdfperson135 wrote:

Basilikos wrote:

officesuppliez wrote:

for those confused as to what would be censored, this would be useful for people who are triggered by certain subjects.
they could censor the words that upset them, ex: abuse, murder, death, etc

officesuppliez wrote:

for those confused as to what would be censored, this would be useful for people who are triggered by certain subjects.
they could censor the words that upset them, ex: abuse, murder, death, etc
Unless they've got a serious mental illness then they can probably get over it eventually.
so what if they do have one, do we just say deal with it?
Just, avoid places in which the trigger is often mentioned?
what if it's suddenly mentioned in a place where it isn't often mentioned?
Cope…
dang ok mr therapist
PaperMarioFan2022
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

a bunch of people wrote:

snipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnippysnipsnippers

Can we please get back on topic?

Last edited by PaperMarioFan2022 (May 29, 2023 14:30:22)

Elijah999999
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:

snipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnipsnip
Can we please get back on topic?
Yes please. I'm about to be smooshed by the quote train.
Nicolasf1109scratch
Scratcher
25 posts

A private censor list.

Wait, How about audio files with cuss words that aren't censored?
Elijah999999
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

Nicolasf1109scratch wrote:

Wait, How about audio files with cuss words that aren't censored?
Scratch already doesn't auto-censor sounds, (very hard technology, even for advanced websites,) so I doubt they would for this either.

Last edited by Elijah999999 (June 5, 2023 22:04:48)

Nicolasf1109scratch
Scratcher
25 posts

A private censor list.

Elijah999999 wrote:

Nicolasf1109scratch wrote:

Wait, How about audio files with cuss words that aren't censored?
Scratch already doesn't auto-censor sounds, (very hard technology, even for advanced websites,) so I doubt they would for this either.
Here is a project with audio that has cuss words: YMW Melly S****dal Remix (feat. Juice WRLD)
It's not censored.

Last edited by Nicolasf1109scratch (June 5, 2023 22:21:42)

Dogs-are-amazing1
Scratcher
500+ posts

A private censor list.

Nicolasf1109scratch wrote:

Elijah999999 wrote:

Nicolasf1109scratch wrote:

Wait, How about audio files with cuss words that aren't censored?
Scratch already doesn't auto-censor sounds, (very hard technology, even for advanced websites,) so I doubt they would for this either.
Here is a project with audio that has cuss words: YMW Melly ******* Remix (feat. Juice WRLD)
It's not censored.
You’re not supposed to have projects with curse words in it. It might be ok if you mute the words, but for this song it’s about something that isn’t for scratch

Edit: so it’s not about something not for scratch, but he repeats a word that isn’t for scratch, idk if you censored it or not

Last edited by Dogs-are-amazing1 (June 5, 2023 22:26:12)

Nicolasf1109scratch
Scratcher
25 posts

A private censor list.

Dogs-are-amazing1 wrote:

Nicolasf1109scratch wrote:

Elijah999999 wrote:

Nicolasf1109scratch wrote:

Wait, How about audio files with cuss words that aren't censored?
Scratch already doesn't auto-censor sounds, (very hard technology, even for advanced websites,) so I doubt they would for this either.
Here is a project with audio that has cuss words: YMW Melly ******* Remix (feat. Juice WRLD)
It's not censored.
You’re not supposed to have projects with curse words in it. It might be ok if you mute the words, but for this song it’s about something that isn’t for scratch

Edit: so it’s not about something not for scratch, but he repeats a word that isn’t for scratch, idk if you censored it or not
I did not censor it.
lapisi
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

Nicolasf1109scratch wrote:

(#479)

Dogs-are-amazing1 wrote:

Nicolasf1109scratch wrote:

Elijah999999 wrote:

Nicolasf1109scratch wrote:

Wait, How about audio files with cuss words that aren't censored?
Scratch already doesn't auto-censor sounds, (very hard technology, even for advanced websites,) so I doubt they would for this either.
Here is a project with audio that has cuss words: YMW Melly ******* Remix (feat. Juice WRLD)
It's not censored.
You’re not supposed to have projects with curse words in it. It might be ok if you mute the words, but for this song it’s about something that isn’t for scratch

Edit: so it’s not about something not for scratch, but he repeats a word that isn’t for scratch, idk if you censored it or not
I did not censor it.
posting projects with inappropriate audio is against the rules here on Scratch
Basilikos
Scratcher
1000+ posts

A private censor list.

Nicolasf1109scratch wrote:

Wait, How about audio files with cuss words that aren't censored?
Not the point and very hard. Reporting is advised.

Powered by DjangoBB