Discuss Scratch

KawaiiCatGirl-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

In my opinion, I find it a tad unfair that banned users can''t view ANY of the site. I mean, what if they were working on a big project? it would be ncie if they could work on it, but not share it, as some people don't like the offline editor,
And, it would be nice if you could still view/favortie projects! Like, there is no harm in viewing stuff, right? Just not be able to comment
Candylanguagegirl
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

I do like this idea- there's always the offline editor if you want to work on something, but imo, it would almost be more of a punishment if you could SEE the comments you were getting and not be able to respond until your ban time was up. Not to mention that it's a somewhat more realistic punishment, and would still let you use the site.
EDIT: Another reason- if you got banned and you have to share a project for school or something, then you could have the project ready to share and be less likely to fail the assignment.

Last edited by Candylanguagegirl (Oct. 30, 2016 12:56:05)

KawaiiCatGirl-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

Candylanguagegirl wrote:

I do like this idea- there's always the offline editor if you want to work on something, but imo, it would almost be more of a punishment if you could SEE the comments you were getting and not be able to respond until your ban time was up. Not to mention that it's a somewhat more realistic punishment, and would still let you use the site.
EDIT: Another reason- if you got banned and you have to share a project for school or something, then you could have the project ready to share and be less likely to fail the assignment.
Some people dislike the offline editor
Techno-CAT
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

Candylanguagegirl wrote:

I do like this idea- there's always the offline editor if you want to work on something, but imo, it would almost be more of a punishment if you could SEE the comments you were getting and not be able to respond until your ban time was up. Not to mention that it's a somewhat more realistic punishment, and would still let you use the site.
EDIT: Another reason- if you got banned and you have to share a project for school or something, then you could have the project ready to share and be less likely to fail the assignment.
Some people dislike the offline editor
Correct, the online editor is useful if you use multiple computers and want to pick up where you left on the other computer.

Techno-CAT
MathlyCat
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

If you aren't IP Banned you should be able to view the website no?

There's a reason to getting banned, and usually it's because your behavior was unfit for the community.
Serving your “time-out” should be done like it always has been.
KawaiiCatGirl-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

MathlyCat wrote:

If you aren't IP Banned you should be able to view the website no?

There's a reason to getting banned, and usually it's because your behavior was unfit for the community.
Serving your “time-out” should be done like it always has been.
Well, there is no harm in viewing things, right?
MathlyCat
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

If you aren't IP Banned you should be able to view the website no?

There's a reason to getting banned, and usually it's because your behavior was unfit for the community.
Serving your “time-out” should be done like it always has been.
Well, there is no harm in viewing things, right?
There is. If a user is saying thins about them, a user misses them, etc.

Anyways, I said:

If you aren't IP Banned can't you view the website
If you are IP Banned, you must have really posed a problem, therefor, would've been best you cannot view it.

Again, watch your actions, and there won't be a problem.
KawaiiCatGirl-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

MathlyCat wrote:

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

If you aren't IP Banned you should be able to view the website no?

There's a reason to getting banned, and usually it's because your behavior was unfit for the community.
Serving your “time-out” should be done like it always has been.
Well, there is no harm in viewing things, right?
There is. If a user is saying thins about them, a user misses them, etc.

Anyways, I said:

If you aren't IP Banned can't you view the website
If you are IP Banned, you must have really posed a problem, therefor, would've been best you cannot view it.

Again, watch your actions, and there won't be a problem.
well, my old acc got banned, and all it was was a misudnerstanding
MathlyCat
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

If you aren't IP Banned you should be able to view the website no?

There's a reason to getting banned, and usually it's because your behavior was unfit for the community.
Serving your “time-out” should be done like it always has been.
Well, there is no harm in viewing things, right?
There is. If a user is saying thins about them, a user misses them, etc.

Anyways, I said:

If you aren't IP Banned can't you view the website
If you are IP Banned, you must have really posed a problem, therefor, would've been best you cannot view it.

Again, watch your actions, and there won't be a problem.
well, my old acc got banned, and all it was was a misudnerstanding
Pssssssst, you realize that you're supposed to appeal or contact the ST, not tell me that you're bypassing a ban
KawaiiCatGirl-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

MathlyCat wrote:

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

If you aren't IP Banned you should be able to view the website no?

There's a reason to getting banned, and usually it's because your behavior was unfit for the community.
Serving your “time-out” should be done like it always has been.
Well, there is no harm in viewing things, right?
There is. If a user is saying thins about them, a user misses them, etc.

Anyways, I said:

If you aren't IP Banned can't you view the website
If you are IP Banned, you must have really posed a problem, therefor, would've been best you cannot view it.

Again, watch your actions, and there won't be a problem.
well, my old acc got banned, and all it was was a misudnerstanding
Pssssssst, you realize that you're supposed to appeal or contact the ST, not tell me that you're bypassing a ban
its unbanned now, duhlike, view my latest project…………

Last edited by KawaiiCatGirl- (Oct. 30, 2016 13:55:59)

MathlyCat
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

If you aren't IP Banned you should be able to view the website no?

There's a reason to getting banned, and usually it's because your behavior was unfit for the community.
Serving your “time-out” should be done like it always has been.
Well, there is no harm in viewing things, right?
There is. If a user is saying thins about them, a user misses them, etc.

Anyways, I said:

If you aren't IP Banned can't you view the website
If you are IP Banned, you must have really posed a problem, therefor, would've been best you cannot view it.

Again, watch your actions, and there won't be a problem.
well, my old acc got banned, and all it was was a misudnerstanding
Pssssssst, you realize that you're supposed to appeal or contact the ST, not tell me that you're bypassing a ban
its unbanned now, duhlike, view my latest project…………
Oh ok don't scare me there

Yeah I don't report bypassers anyways .-.
Well I'm too lazy to
nickeljorn
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

In my opinion, I find it a tad unfair that banned users can''t view ANY of the site. I mean, what if they were working on a big project? it would be ncie if they could work on it, but not share it, as some people don't like the offline editor,
And, it would be nice if you could still view/favortie projects! Like, there is no harm in viewing stuff, right? Just not be able to comment

#support
Bright-Idea
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

nickeljorn wrote:

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

In my opinion, I find it a tad unfair that banned users can''t view ANY of the site. I mean, what if they were working on a big project? it would be ncie if they could work on it, but not share it, as some people don't like the offline editor,
And, it would be nice if you could still view/favortie projects! Like, there is no harm in viewing stuff, right? Just not be able to comment

#support
Please explain why you support. Nonconstructive posts don't add anything to the thread.
TheMonsterOfTheDeep
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

I'm guessing that this is rejected for the reasons outlined in this post by cheddargirl.

cheddargirl wrote:

it doesn't make sense to provide a {free and non-profit!} service who did something so bad that an IP block had to be put into place.
Of course, that post applied only to IP blocks, but I'm guessing it also applies to permanent bans and maybe temp bans as well.
KawaiiCatGirl-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

bump
nickeljorn
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

Support, I've never been banned but it would be awful to be able to do nothing on the site. That's simply unfair.
Firedrake969
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

nickeljorn wrote:

Support, I've never been banned but it would be awful to be able to do nothing on the site. That's simply unfair.
It's not unfair - being banned and not being able to do anything on the site is your punishment. How is that unfair?
KawaiiCatGirl-
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

Firedrake969 wrote:

nickeljorn wrote:

Support, I've never been banned but it would be awful to be able to do nothing on the site. That's simply unfair.
It's not unfair - being banned and not being able to do anything on the site is your punishment. How is that unfair?
It might have been a misunderstanding, or your sibling may have done something, or someone else ina classroom
Firedrake969
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

Firedrake969 wrote:

nickeljorn wrote:

Support, I've never been banned but it would be awful to be able to do nothing on the site. That's simply unfair.
It's not unfair - being banned and not being able to do anything on the site is your punishment. How is that unfair?
It might have been a misunderstanding, or your sibling may have done something, or someone else ina classroom
So they shouldn't be banned in the first place. The consequences in that case are irrelevant.
dvargasews
Scratcher
500+ posts

Banned Users Can Still View Projects

MathlyCat wrote:

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

KawaiiCatGirl- wrote:

MathlyCat wrote:

If you aren't IP Banned you should be able to view the website no?

There's a reason to getting banned, and usually it's because your behavior was unfit for the community.
Serving your “time-out” should be done like it always has been.
Well, there is no harm in viewing things, right?
There is. If a user is saying things about them, a user misses them, etc.

Anyways, I said:

If you aren't IP Banned, can't you view the website?
If you are IP Banned, you must have really posed a problem, therefor, would've been best you cannot view it.

Again, watch your actions, and there won't be a problem.
Well, my old acc got banned, and all it was was a misunderstanding.
Pssssssst, you realize that you're supposed to appeal or contact the ST, not tell me that you're bypassing a ban
It's unbanned now, duhlike, view my latest project…………
Oh ok don't scare me there

Yeah I don't report bypassers anyways .-.
Well I'm too lazy to
If you're just logging out and viewing projects without logging in, is that really a bad thing to do? If you can't do what you were banned for doing, then is that really a problem? If it was, wouldn't the Scratch Team members IP ban everyone whom they banned and not just account-ban them?









This message is not in a quote.
This message is in a quote.

Pretty smart, right?

Last edited by dvargasews (Jan. 6, 2017 20:03:31)

Powered by DjangoBB