Add REAL support & no support buttons (5 supporters)

Minecratch_project

bigpuppy wrote:
No support. You should give a reason why, it's not all about points and all that.

-bigpuppy

Repeat: that's why i added phase 2 and phase 3

bigpuppy

Minecratch_project wrote:
bigpuppy wrote:
No support. You should give a reason why, it's not all about points and all that.

-bigpuppy

Repeat: that's why i added phase 2 and phase 3

Phase 2 and 3 don't say what I was talking about. Everyone should give a reason, not just the ST.

-bigpuppy

Abstract-

No Support. The ST are busy, they would be overwhelmed. Also, Supports don't matter. What matters is how the suggestion would help make Scratch better.

CellularData

Abstract- wrote:
No Support. The ST are busy, they would be overwhelmed. Also, Supports don't matter. What matters is how the suggestion would help make Scratch better.

You just said “Supports don't matter” and “No Support” in one post…

jokebookservice1

CellularData wrote:
Abstract- wrote:
No Support. The ST are busy, they would be overwhelmed. Also, Supports don't matter. What matters is how the suggestion would help make Scratch better.
You just said “Supports don't matter” and “No Support” in one post…

True. That single section of the post did not help the suggestion get implemented or not, but neither did the word “is” yet it was still used

Ziggy741

No support. It's not voting. When users say what they think, they are saying their opinion. So what users think shouldn't affect what others think. It's just an opinion.

Abstract-

CellularData wrote:
Abstract- wrote:
No Support. The ST are busy, they would be overwhelmed. Also, Supports don't matter. What matters is how the suggestion would help make Scratch better.
You just said “Supports don't matter” and “No Support” in one post…

I meant “Supports don't matter” as in, “Supports do not make a suggestion good or bad.”

Minecratch_project

bigpuppy wrote:
Minecratch_project wrote:
bigpuppy wrote:
No support. You should give a reason why, it's not all about points and all that.

-bigpuppy

Repeat: that's why i added phase 2 and phase 3
Phase 2 and 3 don't say what I was talking about. Everyone should give a reason, not just the ST.

-bigpuppy

Yes, but it will dont remove the commenting on posts

Minecratch_project

Hmn, i knew this was going to go wrong

NanoRook

Minecratch_project wrote:
Sheep_maker wrote:
I think we should just get rid of support, no support, semi support, and indifferent and just get out the reasons and “discuss” (aka the button you probably clicked on to get here). Green, yellow, and red doesn't really fit Scratch's blue-and-grey color scheme. Phase 1 is encouraging unconstructive “discussion” which is against the CG's. Phase 2 and 3 is a bit confusing because the ST is already working on a bunch of stuff so it will take a really long time for all those suggestions to be implemented. And I don't think they'd add the block here, they'd probably add it to Scratch 3.0

Well maybe we can use that too

LP_Play wrote:
Supported.

Thanks!

JakeCarroll wrote:
Support. I hardly ever see the ST comment on a suggestion.

That why im actually doing this

NanoRook wrote:
No support. It's canonical to every forum and removing it would make no sense.

canonical? what are you saying?

Let me google that for you.

pinkieofthepies

i agree with most everyone here, as i have said in my first post, the points dont matter! Just the strong opinions, and if it would make scratch better.

think of it like this.

Somebody says

“HEY! lets unban fnaf cuz its not scary!!!!!”
although the ST has rejected this many times, and its just a matter of opinion, people are going to support. and not support,
A bunch of new scratchers who have/. have not read the stickys will support along with probably a few bots (they like to push buttons)
THEN the ST has to deal with a rejected suggestion and it wastes their time answering rejected things and looking at it instead of making scratch better.

sorry for the rant

No support

Minecratch_project

NanoRook wrote:
Minecratch_project wrote:
Sheep_maker wrote:
I think we should just get rid of support, no support, semi support, and indifferent and just get out the reasons and “discuss” (aka the button you probably clicked on to get here). Green, yellow, and red doesn't really fit Scratch's blue-and-grey color scheme. Phase 1 is encouraging unconstructive “discussion” which is against the CG's. Phase 2 and 3 is a bit confusing because the ST is already working on a bunch of stuff so it will take a really long time for all those suggestions to be implemented. And I don't think they'd add the block here, they'd probably add it to Scratch 3.0

Well maybe we can use that too

LP_Play wrote:
Supported.

Thanks!

JakeCarroll wrote:
Support. I hardly ever see the ST comment on a suggestion.

That why im actually doing this

NanoRook wrote:
No support. It's canonical to every forum and removing it would make no sense.

canonical? what are you saying?

Let me google that for you.

I actually know what means

OK, this is going bad, im think im closing the fourm

pinkieofthepies

Minecratch_project wrote:
*snipptey snipo*

You see my post?

Minecratch_project

pinkieofthepies wrote:
Minecratch_project wrote:
*snipptey snipo*

You see my post?

yes

PD: snipptey snipo?

pinkieofthepies

Minecratch_project wrote:
pinkieofthepies wrote:
Minecratch_project wrote:
*snipptey snipo*

You see my post?

yes

PD: snipptey snipo?

yeah, it was supposes to say snippety snip XD

Minecratch_project

pinkieofthepies wrote:
Minecratch_project wrote:
pinkieofthepies wrote:
Minecratch_project wrote:
*snipptey snipo*

You see my post?

yes

PD: snipptey snipo?
yeah, it was supposes to say snippety snip XD

However goodbye and ‘'thanks’' for the support

pvz_pro

no support, just report the topic to be reveiwed

bigpuppy

Minecratch_project wrote:
bigpuppy wrote:
Minecratch_project wrote:
bigpuppy wrote:
No support. You should give a reason why, it's not all about points and all that.

-bigpuppy

Repeat: that's why i added phase 2 and phase 3
Phase 2 and 3 don't say what I was talking about. Everyone should give a reason, not just the ST.

-bigpuppy

Yes, but it will dont remove the commenting on posts

Still, it's not about numbers…

-bigpuppy

pianogirl84

Why do the # of supports matter that much? (I've done it too, but… >_<)

gdpr533f604550b2f20900645890

Sorry, but I'm going to have to no-support this suggestion. Scratch contains users of all ages, some of which may be too immature to make educated voting decisions. Many times, I have seen a suggestion be no-supported because it seems to confusing or is misunderstood, or on a whim, especially programming suggestions. Some people may not realize how passionate people feel about a suggestion, and their own reasons against it do not reflect its potential benefits. I have even considered asking people to refrain from supporting/no-supporting completely on my own suggestions, and instead discussing it, because of unconstructive downvotes. If your suggestion was to be implemented, then poor voting decisions could significantly hurt suggestions. Like Zro716 said, logical reasons should be more significant that numbers.

Last edited by gdpr533f604550b2f20900645890 (July 15, 2016 20:54:26)

Discuss Scratch