Discuss Scratch

rollercoasterfan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

I have some studio ideas. I'm going to post them here:

1. Messages

Studio messages are annoying. Like, REALLY annoying. But we can't remove them, because they're actually really useful. I'm in a few studios where I really need to know when someone comments, and that's it. Here are some ideas that me and some other people came up with in that studio.

1.1 Only when you follow
When you follow a forum topic, you get messages. When you follow a user, you get info about them on the What's Happening. But, following a studio is really just like loving it. Instead, even if you curate a studio, you only get messages when you follow the studio. When you accept a curator application, you are automatically set as a follower, which you can always unfollow, of course. Now, you can get messages for studios you don't curate, such as an SDS studio.

1.2 Comments
You only get messages from comments. Anytime someone comments on the studio, all curators of it get a message, like it's your own project. You can also check an option to only get messages from comments, or get messages from both comments, plus the regular studio messages, which won't count comments, in this case.

1.3 Turn 'em off!
Pretty simple, turn them completely off!

1.4 Combination, or choose
We can combine some of these ideas, or all, or we could allow people to choose what options they want. Best of both worlds.

1.5 Opinions?

Supporters:
1. rollercoasterfan, Iloverollercoasters, Deerleg, Blank1234, Zekrom01, Cream_E_Cookie, Nether_before
2. rollercoasterfan, Iloverollercoasters, Zekrom01, scrooge200, Cream_E_Cookie, Nether_before
3. rollercoasterfan, DaSpudLord, Iloverollercoasters, Blank1234, Zekrom01, Cream_E_Cookie, Nether_before, ev3coolexit987654, scratchinghead
4. rollercoasterfan, Iloverollercoasters, Blank1234, Zekrom01, scrooge200, Cream_E_Cookie, Nether_before

Semi-supporters
2. DaSpudLord, Deerleg, ev3coolexit987654
3. Deerleg

No supporters:
1. DaSpudLord, scrooge200, ev3coolexit987654, scratchinghead
2. Blank1234, scratchinghead
3. scrooge200
4. DaSpudLord, ev3coolexit987654, scratchinghead

2. Comments

The comments in a studio are really useful, and I use them a ton. But, some things could be changed.

2.1 Deleting
We can delete comments on projects, why not studios? To keep things from crashing, only the owner or all managers can delete comments.

2.2 Seperating
Studios have different parts attached. Now, each part can have a comment section! Basically, this devides the comments up. Managers (or just owners) can create sections, or just have a general comment section. For example, I can create one called Questions, one called Discuss, and maybe one called Project Suggestions! You can easily tab between them.

2.3 Opinions?

Supporters:
1. rollercoasterfan, Deerleg, Iloverollercoasters, scrooge200, Cream_E_Cookie, scratchinghead
2. rollercoasterfan, Iloverollercoasters, Zekrom01, scrooge200, Cream_E_Cookie, Nether_before

Semi-supporters
1. DaSpudLord, Zekrom01, ev3coolexit987654
2. Deerleg

No supporters:
1. Blank1234, Nether_before
2. DaSpudLord, Blank1234, ev3coolexit987654, scratchinghead

3. Descriptions

Studio descriptions are really useful, since they tell people all about the studio. But, sometimes they don't get the point across. By the way, I'd love it if all of these could get put in project descriptions as well.

3.1 Remove character limit
Remove the character limit. Someone told me that there's a character limit, and there's no point. If there isn't one, please tell me. Thanks!

3.2 Formatting
Since you can have so much information to put in a studio description, formatting would really come handy. I can get the point across so much better in a forum thread than I can in a studio description, because of formatting.

3.3 Clicky links
When you're a manager, you can edit the description, but, you can't click any links. A way to switch between Read-Only Mode and Edit Mode would be awesome, so I can still click those links.

3.4 Opinions?

Supporters:
1. rollercoasterfan, DaSpudLord, Iloverollercoasters, Zekrom01, scrooge200, Cream_E_Cookie, ev3coolexit987654
2. rollercoasterfan, Deerleg, Iloverollercoasters, Zekrom01, scrooge200, Cream_E_Cookie, Nether_before
3. rollercoasterfan, DaSpudLord, Deerleg, Iloverollercoasters, scrooge200, Cream_E_Cookie, Nether_before, ev3coolexit987654, scratchinghead

Semi-supporters:
1. Deerleg, Nether_before
2. DaSpudLord, ev3coolexit987654
3. Blank1234

No supporters:
1. Blank1234, scratchinghead
2. Blank1234
3.

4. Curators

Curators are probably the most important part of a studio. Without them, a good studio won't exist, really. The curator system is great, but some things could be added.

4.1 Demoting
You can promote someone, but in order to demote them, you have to remove them and reinvite them. Not good. All managers can hover over another manager, where a demote button will pop up, like when a manager hovers over a curator. You can demote yourself

4.2 Opinions?

Supporters:
1. rollercoasterfan, wayyyy, DaSpudLord, Deerleg, Iloverollercoasters, Blank1234, Zekrom01, scrooge200, Cream_E_Cookie, Nether_before, ev3coolexit987654, scratchinghead

No supporters:
1.

5. Final words and how to support

I still have more stuff to say!

5.1 TL,DR (Too Long, Didn't Read)
Go to the top and read down.

5.2 Ideas
Got more studio ideas? Things I can change? Shout 'em out!

5.3 How to support
Since I have so many ideas, it's hard to support them! Copy and paste this form to support:
1. Messages
1. S/NS (Support or no support)
2. S/NS
3. S/NS
4. S/NS
5. Opinion: (give your feedback)

2. Comments
1. S/NS
2. S/NS
3. Opinion:

3. Descriptions
1. S/NS
2. S/NS
3. S/NS
4. Opinion:

4. Curators
1. S/NS
2. Opinion:

That's it! Thanks for reading!

Last edited by rollercoasterfan (Sept. 14, 2015 13:58:02)

wayyyy
Scratcher
500+ posts

Studio Ideas

Support for 4. I forgot to read the rest
rollercoasterfan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

wayyyy wrote:

Support for 4. I forgot to read the rest
4 as in the curators?
DaSpudLord
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

1.1: No support. What if I want to receive messages, but don't want to follow?
1.2: Uh… semi-support, I guess? I think 1.3 would be better.
1.3: Support.
1.4: No support, just idea 1.3 would suffice.

2.1: Semi-support, there might be a reason you can't already do this.
2.2: No support. Is it worth the ST's time?

3.1: Support.
3.2: Semi-support, I don't really see the need for formatting stuff outside of the editor. Honestly, I don't even think we need it in the forums…
3.3: Support.

4.1: Support.

Last edited by DaSpudLord (Aug. 25, 2015 01:19:08)

Deerleg
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

What a long post!

1. Messages
1. So you're making curating a studio like following a studio now and following a studio like curating it? What's the point of that?
2. What about if you want to get messages only when someone adds projects?
3. I think this has been rejected but I'm not completely sure and I'm probably wrong.
2. Comments
1. Support (but isn't this in already?)
2. Support 25% - I don't think this is particularly needed but I can see why you would want it.
3. Description
1. I think it's just the invisible 5000 character limit, but I don't know.
2. Support!
3. Support!
4. Curators
1. Support.

EDIT: While I was typing this three people responded before me XD

Last edited by Deerleg (Aug. 25, 2015 01:19:20)

rollercoasterfan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

DaSpudLord wrote:

1.1: No support. What if I want to receive messages, but don't want to follow?
1.2: Uh… semi-support, I guess? I think 1.3 would be better.
1.3: Support.
1.4: No support, just idea 1.3 would suffice.

2.1: Semi-support, there might be a reason you can't already do this.
2.2: No support. Is it worth the ST's time?

3.1: Support.
3.2: Semi-support, I don't really see the need for formatting stuff outside of the editor. Honestly, I don't even think we need it in the forums…
3.3: Support.

4.1: Support.
1.1 You could choose what you want.
1.2 I personally would like this more than 1.3

2.2 I don't know myself xD

3.2 It is.

Deerleg wrote:

What a long post!

1. Messages
1. So you're making curating a studio like following a studio now and following a studio like curating it? What's the point of that?
2. What about if you want to get messages only when someone adds projects?
3. I think this has been rejected but I'm not completely sure and I'm probably wrong.
2. Comments
1. Support (but isn't this in already?)
2. Support 25% - I don't think this is particularly needed but I can see why you would want it.
3. Description
1. I think it's just the invisible 5000 character limit, but I don't know.
2. Support!
3. Support!
4. Curators
1. Support.

EDIT: While I was typing this three people responded before me XD
1.1 So you can add projects to a studio, but don't need to recieve messages. You wouldn't remove yourself though. And if you wanted messages for studios you don't curate.
1.2 I guess that could also be an option.

2.1 Nope.

3.1 Hmm, good point. But if you have a loooong studio description
wayyyy
Scratcher
500+ posts

Studio Ideas

rollercoasterfan wrote:

wayyyy wrote:

Support for 4. I forgot to read the rest
4 as in the curators?
4.1 Yes.
rollercoasterfan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

wayyyy wrote:

rollercoasterfan wrote:

wayyyy wrote:

Support for 4. I forgot to read the rest
4 as in the curators?
4.1 Yes.
What about the rest? Support, no support, or semi-support?
Iloverollercoasters
Scratcher
100+ posts

Studio Ideas

Support!
Deerleg
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

rollercoasterfan wrote:

Deerleg wrote:

What a long post!

1. Messages
1. So you're making curating a studio like following a studio now and following a studio like curating it? What's the point of that?
2. What about if you want to get messages only when someone adds projects?
3. I think this has been rejected but I'm not completely sure and I'm probably wrong.
2. Comments
1. Support (but isn't this in already?)
2. Support 25% - I don't think this is particularly needed but I can see why you would want it.
3. Description
1. I think it's just the invisible 5000 character limit, but I don't know.
2. Support!
3. Support!
4. Curators
1. Support.

EDIT: While I was typing this three people responded before me XD
1.1 So you can add projects to a studio, but don't need to recieve messages. You wouldn't remove yourself though. And if you wanted messages for studios you don't curate.
1.2 I guess that could also be an option.

2.1 Nope.

3.1 Hmm, good point. But if you have a loooong studio description
1.1: Oh, okay. Support!
3.1: So we should remove the invisible 5000 character limit from projects too?
Blank1234
Scratcher
500+ posts

Studio Ideas

1.1: Support
1.2: No support
1.3: Support
1.4: Support

2.1: No support
2.2: No support

3.1: No support
3.2: No support
3.3: Undecided

4.1: Support
rollercoasterfan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

Deerleg wrote:

3.1: So we should remove the invisible 5000 character limit from projects too?
I guess.

Blank1234 wrote:

1.1: Support
1.2: No support
1.3: Support
1.4: Support

2.1: No support
2.2: No support

3.1: No support
3.2: No support
3.3: Undecided

4.1: Support
Why don't you support some?
Zekrom01
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

That's a lot of things. But here ya go…

1.1: Support
1.2: Support
1.3: Support
1.4: You probably guessed it… support.
1.5: I completely support all of them. Maybe you could get a message if someone accepts your curator invite?

2.1: Semi-support, as some manager troll might delete comments with important info.
2.2: Support although some studios might not use it.
2.3: In conclusion, semi-support as per number 2.1.

3.1: Support, should happen in project descriptions and about me sections too.
3.2: Support but what would be the format?
3.3: What do you mean?
3.4 Support, in conclusion, but be more specific on 3.3 like what would the format be?

4.1: Support, although I probably wouldn't do that.
4.2: support.

5.2:
Maybe you could add a feature to stop becoming a curator of a studio.
Add a message if someone you invited to be a curator has accepted the invite.
Add a message if you've been promoted to manager.
Block studio invites from certain people.

That's just about it. I really hope all of this gets implemented!
scrooge200
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

1. Messages
1. No support. Go see if all the studios you're curating are in your “Studios I'm Following”.
2. Support.
3. No support, some people like studio notifications. I'll change to semi-support if it's optional.
4. Support so much.
5. Opinion: Some of these ideas I like, some I don't.

2. Comments
1. Support.
2. Support.
3. Opinion: These ideas are great! I personally don't use studios, but this will come in handy.

3. Descriptions
1. Support.
2. Support.
3. Support.
4. Opinion: As I said before, “These ideas are great! I personally don't use studios, but this will come in handy.”

4. Curators
1. Support.
2. Opinion: We can promote, why not demote?
rollercoasterfan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

Thanks for the feedback everybody! I really appreciate it.
Zekrom01
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

rollercoasterfan wrote:

Thanks for the feedback everybody! I really appreciate it.
no problem
rollercoasterfan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

Bump!
Cream_E_Cookie
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

Support for all
rollercoasterfan
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

Bumpo!
Nether_before
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Studio Ideas

Messages- Support for all, especially for the last one.
Comments- No support for deleting, it could be used to PM. Support for separating as long as there's a limit on how many sections you can have.
Descriptions- support for all but removing the character limit, which I semi-support as it could make some descriptions harder to read due to the sheer amount of text.
Curators- Support.

Powered by DjangoBB