Discuss Scratch
- rollercoasterfan
-
1000+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
Just today (July 15, 2015), a new feature was added to scratch, which can have projects in your language show in the explore page. It's great, but i have a few thoughts.
The new explore feature for different languages doesn't really work (at least how I expected it to work.) I wanted to test this out, so I switched my language to spanish. In the explore page, I switched to the projects in Espanol and saw a couple of spanish projects, but most were still English. I switched to Edible Scratch, and once again, it didn't work. I know that this (probably) wasn't designed for the joke languages, (but how can projects be written in Edible Scratch?) My question is how the different language thing works. On one of the projects I found under the spanish section I checked, and there was nothing spanish. While this feature is nice, it doesn't help those who don't speak English, because quite frankly, it doesn't work. If there was a way to detect if the project title, instructions and notes and credits had at least a good chunk of a certain language, it might count it. I'm guessing that's how it currently works, but it doesn't work right. What would be the best way to improve this for those who don't speak English to have?
Now that I mentioned all that, if almost all parts of the website like studios and the search engine had something like this, it would be really nice, because almost everything on Scratch is English. Of course that would mean a brand new search engine, but we've really needed that for years anyway. I know this is a lot, but a translator, even just google translate to translate comments, forum posts, notes and credits, etc. would be awesome for those non-English speakers. Having more translate options could really improve the website, and invite more non-English speakers to join Scratch, making it a way more diverse place.
Are there any other ways that Scratch could have translating options for non-English speakers? Give me your thoughts, and support!
The new explore feature for different languages doesn't really work (at least how I expected it to work.) I wanted to test this out, so I switched my language to spanish. In the explore page, I switched to the projects in Espanol and saw a couple of spanish projects, but most were still English. I switched to Edible Scratch, and once again, it didn't work. I know that this (probably) wasn't designed for the joke languages, (but how can projects be written in Edible Scratch?) My question is how the different language thing works. On one of the projects I found under the spanish section I checked, and there was nothing spanish. While this feature is nice, it doesn't help those who don't speak English, because quite frankly, it doesn't work. If there was a way to detect if the project title, instructions and notes and credits had at least a good chunk of a certain language, it might count it. I'm guessing that's how it currently works, but it doesn't work right. What would be the best way to improve this for those who don't speak English to have?
Now that I mentioned all that, if almost all parts of the website like studios and the search engine had something like this, it would be really nice, because almost everything on Scratch is English. Of course that would mean a brand new search engine, but we've really needed that for years anyway. I know this is a lot, but a translator, even just google translate to translate comments, forum posts, notes and credits, etc. would be awesome for those non-English speakers. Having more translate options could really improve the website, and invite more non-English speakers to join Scratch, making it a way more diverse place.
Are there any other ways that Scratch could have translating options for non-English speakers? Give me your thoughts, and support!
- Iloverollercoasters
-
100+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
Support! This will work very well on scratch. Sometimes I like to play around (not actually) and read other languages for fun. Nice suggest! data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b027b/b027b15252ac2f1ffe673ff66a9897adff4389d8" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/242ad/242adba531b884b33e91657891aa5348e54af0d3" alt=""
- stickfiregames
-
1000+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
I think it currently works by the project creator's language setting, going by the wording of the tab (“Created in English”). They way you described sounds like a better way to do it, so support for that.
- Meese123
-
100+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
Support for reasons in above posts (excluding bumps)
- CGRises
-
500+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
and the post above. Support for reasons in above posts (excluding bumps)
- rollercoasterfan
-
1000+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
I'm surprised this hasn't gotten much attention lately….
Bump!
Bump!
- CatsUnited
-
1000+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
I support, it needs a better algorithm, but why is there a choice to search for Edible Scratch projects?
- rollercoasterfan
-
1000+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
Because it's considered a language. I support, it needs a better algorithm, but why is there a choice to search for Edible Scratch projects?
Even though it isn't….
- PrincessPanda_test_
-
1000+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
Support! Tested with Japanese and it got your result!
- rollercoasterfan
-
1000+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
How many times do I need to bump this topic?
- Iloverollercoasters
-
100+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
How many times do I need to bump this topic?
I don't know.
- DaSpudLord
-
1000+ posts
Better Translate Options for Scratch
1. But how would the servers be able to tell what language a word is in? That would involve programming the Scratch site with every word from every language that Scratch can be translated to.
2. Support, perhaps a button next to the “report” button that says “Translate to <current language>”.
2. Support, perhaps a button next to the “report” button that says “Translate to <current language>”.