Liking/upvoting comments

DangerPuppy10

king of page 50 no edit

wouldn't this fall under multiple rejected suggestions about social media?

AliMASTER430258

DangerPuppy10 wrote:
(#981)
king of page 50 no edit

wouldn't this fall under multiple rejected suggestions about social media?

(i think) its linked in TOLoRs as not rejected, i didn't check yet

41919

I just think liking comments is something that Scratch should already have. Of course, just like projects, there can’t be dislikes, but still. Maybe it could use the love/favorite system that projects already use.

Last edited by 41919 (Oct. 20, 2024 02:17:57)

Boss_1s

bump

mastergamerx-details

DangerPuppy10 wrote:
king of page 50 no edit

wouldn't this fall under multiple rejected suggestions about social media?

Having a dislike button for comments is rejected, a like/love button is not

KitKat341b

I think that would be a good idea, but the most recent comment should stay at the top.

Moss-Star44

Z-zap wrote:
Lately, I have been seeing some hilarious comments, and I think that people should be able to upvote them.

Same, but prevent things like 'If _____ then like the comment"

Uhh

HelloJelloPeople

5_g wrote:
lm@o that is another example of the scratch team straight up lying, social media is the focus of scratch now and they know it

It never was, and will never be.
That being said, liking comments would be almost no different to loving projects.

8to16

bump

nikky10000000

Fr but this would lead to like beggars and such

spraypaintdev

Support. The normal wrokaround to this is to reply with “: )” or “: D” but then it gets really weird if that person replies back with one of these emoticons.

HelloJelloPeople

nikky10000000 wrote:
Fr but this would lead to like beggars and such

does this not exist with projects now?

HighlaneGamingStudio

I don't support upvoting, but I would support liking a comment as a way of replying “I agree.” I would also support the option to pin a comment that a Scratcher put up on their own project at the top of the comments list while still allowing other people to comment about the project below that.

lapisi

HighlaneGamingStudio wrote:
(#993)
I don't support upvoting, but I would support liking a comment as a way of replying “I agree.” I would also support the option to pin a comment that a Scratcher put up on their own project at the top of the comments list while still allowing other people to comment about the project below that.

so maybe an “agree” button instead of a like/upvote button?

amkapadia

yes exactly.

GarbagePanda

It could be used instead of spamming “cool” or “agree” on posts, but on the other hand, like mentioned above, it could lead to competition and spamming to earn more loves.

mastergamerx-details

GarbagePanda wrote:
It could be used instead of spamming “cool” or “agree” on posts, but on the other hand, like mentioned above, it could lead to competition and spamming to earn more loves.

Why would someone love spam?

nikky10000000

Bump

Last edited by nikky10000000 (Nov. 30, 2024 01:56:27)

mingo-gag

this should be bumped I support this suggestion :3

mumu245

mastergamerx-details wrote:
(#997)
GarbagePanda wrote:
It could be used instead of spamming “cool” or “agree” on posts, but on the other hand, like mentioned above, it could lead to competition and spamming to earn more loves.
Why would someone love spam?

Spam should be reported, and there will still be people that would report it. If the default sort order is still time (but there is an option to sort by loves), I think the incentive to spam would decrease.

Discuss Scratch