The Official List of Rejected Suggestions

XCartooonX

MythosLore wrote:
Gamer_Logan819 wrote:
Skibidi toilet awareness month is sadly rejected https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/topic/762247/
It was obviously a joke (and a moderator never confirmed that it was rejected). Never mind, it's rejected.

Honestly, I bet that there could be an entire rejected suggestion that reads “Create special weeks or months on the website for unimportant events.” “Unimportant” stuff in this case could be the Skibidi Toilet Awareness Month suggestion that was rejected, but I would need to find a better word than “unimportant.” Something a lot more specific…

Zydrolic

XCartooonX wrote:
(#8510)
Honestly, I bet that there could be an entire rejected suggestion that reads “Create special weeks or months on the website for unimportant events.” “Unimportant” stuff in this case could be the Skibidi Toilet Awareness Month suggestion that was rejected, but I would need to find a better word than “unimportant.” Something a lot more specific…

Create special events for made-up events

Za-Chary

INSERT-USER_NAME wrote:
Is there a section on this page for unrejected suggestions?

If you are asking if I have a section for suggestions that were once rejected but are no longer rejected, then no. I'm not even sure if I'm aware of any such suggestions, at least, not ones that are worth putting on this list.

XCartooonX wrote:
- snip -

Until the Scratch Team states otherwise, I assume that special events in general are not rejected. If anyone wants to suggest a special event, they are free to do so, but it should align with Scratch's values, and in particular be related to Scratch in some way. But this is where the Scratch Design Goals come in, so this is basically already covered elsewhere.

MythosLore

Za-Chary wrote:
INSERT-USER_NAME wrote:
Is there a section on this page for unrejected suggestions?
If you are asking if I have a section for suggestions that were once rejected but are no longer rejected, then no. I'm not even sure if I'm aware of any such suggestions, at least, not ones that are worth putting on this list.

“Pi block” was one example, but aside from that, I don't know of any.

Za-Chary

(Almost) no posts this whole week? Wild. I'm just going to make a short note about “Explicitly celebrate Pride Month instead of Wellness Month” seemingly being rejected:
https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/post/7995360/
https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/post/7996968/
I'm not going to add this to the list at this time because it's slightly unclear at this time as to whether the Scratch Team will be explicitly celebrating Pride Month — and I don't think Wellness Month will prevent the Scratch Team from making/featuring projects/studios related to Pride.

1RocK0StaR1

Was the “Censor the Words (You get the point)” suggestion pulled back? I can't find it anywhere.

scratchttn

1RocK0StaR1 wrote:
Was the “Censor the Words (You get the point)” suggestion pulled back? I can't find it anywhere.

red

Last edited by scratchttn (June 4, 2024 17:28:28)

julmik6478

I think that “13+ version of scratch” should say “13+ or another age-resticted version of scratch” beacuse I think that other age resticted versions of scratch like 16+ or 18+ are also rejected.

julmik6478

Beeter workaround of 1.2 without reset timer:

when green flag clicked
forever
set [stop clicked v] to (timer)
end
when [timer v] > (stop clicked)
script here::grey

MagicCoder330

Another one bites the dust

https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/discuss/topic/765154/

plantskym2

Fixing mass reporting was just rejected

PaperMarioFan2022

Does the topic that I recently posted warrant as a rejection?

Xzillox

plantskym2 wrote:
Fixing mass reporting was just rejected

that seems like it wasn't quite rejected, just closed because it wasn't providing an actual solution (which paddle says as the reason why it can't be considered). I think if there was an actual solution proposed then it may not have been rejected so fast

Last edited by Xzillox (June 4, 2024 21:22:51)

starlightsparker

plantskym2 wrote:
Fixing mass reporting was just rejected

That’s not rejected. Paddle said there’s no proposed solution on the suggestion so the suggestion isn’t valid. Not that it would still not be valid if it had a solution in it.

MythosLore

A stamp limit was rejected, although I've never seen it come up before.

Spaceandmoon1

MythosLore wrote:
A stamp limit was rejected, although I've never seen it come up before.

What's a stamp?

Catscratcher07

Spaceandmoon1 wrote:
MythosLore wrote:
A stamp limit was rejected, although I've never seen it come up before.
What's a stamp?

pen extension, makes a drawing of the stamped sprite in pen.

Catscratcher07

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:
Does the topic that I recently posted warrant as a rejection?

link?

PaperMarioFan2022

Catscratcher07 wrote:
PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:
Does the topic that I recently posted warrant as a rejection?
link?

It got dustbinned, but it was about discouraging “I hate” topic titles.

Catscratcher07

PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:
Catscratcher07 wrote:
PaperMarioFan2022 wrote:
Does the topic that I recently posted warrant as a rejection?
link?
It got dustbinned, but it was about discouraging “I hate” topic titles.

I'm pretty sure “I hate” topics are already banned, so that would be closed as already implemented, not rejected.

Discuss Scratch