This suggestion isn't just about pronouns in comments

HeliosTheSuperior

popjam12 wrote:
Sliverus wrote:
musicROCKS013 wrote:
-TheEmptyVoidOfSpace wrote:
I totally agree. This topic is getting lots of unnecessary hate.
Uhhh… I support this… sorry if it came off as hate or something
I know you’re not talking to me but I want to say in the quote the user quoted, I didn’t mean to say you were hating on anything!!

Bruh I’m king of 10th page
offtopic: why is this conversation getting dramatic
also im the prince of page 10 i think
anyway
like either 1 person or a few people have said before, it could increase loading time if there is tons of comments/posts

but you have to press load more all the time to see more comments

quing of page

Last edited by HeliosTheSuperior (Aug. 16, 2022 23:35:58)

musicROCKS013

Unity_and_Cq wrote:
2. If you “forget it” (though it’s not a song you need to memorize) you can just open said person’s profile.

musicROCKS013 wrote:
2. It is if you're on a slow device. Even if you aren't on a slow device, it would help be a constant reminder of whatever is in someone's about me. You may forget it and need to skim it often to remember some stuff about them.

Unity_and_Cq wrote:
1. If it takes too long, I assume you wouldn’t bother trying to open a new tab anyway.

Which is a way this suggestion would help! You see, if the about me was loaded on the page already, then you wouldn't have to bother trying to open a new tab, and could hover over the icon to see their about me.

Unity_and_Cq

musicROCKS013 wrote:
Unity_and_Cq wrote:
2. If you “forget it” (though it’s not a song you need to memorize) you can just open said person’s profile.
musicROCKS013 wrote:
2. It is if you're on a slow device. Even if you aren't on a slow device, it would help be a constant reminder of whatever is in someone's about me. You may forget it and need to skim it often to remember some stuff about them.

Unity_and_Cq wrote:
1. If it takes too long, I assume you wouldn’t bother trying to open a new tab anyway.
Which is a way this suggestion would help! You see, if the about me was loaded on the page already, then you wouldn't have to bother trying to open a new tab, and could hover over the icon to see their about me.

It’s not helpful though. Go and tell me it’s helpful for those on slow devices. With all these buttons, it will be slower to open up pages on Scratch which defeats your purpose.
And hover?? Do you understand how annoying that could be? Hovering over a question mark by accident and a thing pops up? Just no.

musicROCKS013

Unity_and_Cq wrote:
It’s not helpful though. Go and tell me it’s helpful for those on slow devices. With all these buttons, it will be slower to open up pages on Scratch which defeats your purpose.

I still don't think it would slow it down more than opening up a new tab.

it's more helpful for those on slow devices

Unity_and_Cq wrote:
And hover?? Do you understand how annoying that could be? Hovering over a question mark by accident and a thing pops up? Just no.

Well you're the one that keeps saying this will save a click…

Last edited by musicROCKS013 (Aug. 16, 2022 23:45:19)

____TheAroace

Uhh guys, let's not start debates over this

Eagle138

Ok, ok, ok. Everyone, please read this. We acknowledge the question of ‘Is it necessary?’ and we acknowledge that there are arguments for both sides. Please, before you make another post about it, think: are there any other problems you want to point out? This discussion is going around in circles, and it seems to me that this topic could soon get closed. We can consider the problem unresolved for now, but please try to think of something else to talk about.

musicROCKS013

So, should this (?) be activated by you hovering over it or a click on it?

Last edited by musicROCKS013 (Aug. 17, 2022 00:04:54)

HeliosTheSuperior

yall all repeating the same arguments for 11 pages

Eagle138

musicROCKS013 wrote:
So, should this (?) be activated by you hovering over it or a click on it?

I was thinking click because of the interface issues that Za-Chary mentioned earlier (how if it was hover, accidentally hovering would be annoying to get off)

musicROCKS013

Eagle138 wrote:
I was thinking click because of the interface issues that Za-Chary mentioned earlier (how if it was hover, accidentally hovering would be annoying to get off)

It could be hover, but take a little bit of time to appear or something. So, if you're scrolling past it it won't detect it.

Eagle138

musicROCKS013 wrote:
Eagle138 wrote:
I was thinking click because of the interface issues that Za-Chary mentioned earlier (how if it was hover, accidentally hovering would be annoying to get off)
It could be hover, but take a little bit of time to appear or something. So, if you're scrolling past it it won't detect it.

Possibly. I feel like in that case, click would be faster anyway, though.

Unity_and_Cq

musicROCKS013 wrote:
So, should this (?) be activated by you hovering over it or a click on it?

Hovering would be annoying because every five seconds another about me would appear.

A new problem: How many people would use this thing if it was implemented rather than just clicking the profile? A lot of users are already used to clicking the profile so adding this in would be confusing.

musicROCKS013 wrote:
It could be hover, but take a little bit of time to appear or something. So, if you're scrolling past it it won't detect it.

Seems overly complicated.

Last edited by Unity_and_Cq (Aug. 17, 2022 00:21:30)

musicROCKS013

Unity_and_Cq wrote:
A new problem: How many people would use this thing if it was implemented rather than just clicking the profile? A lot of users are already used to clicking the profile so adding this in would be confusing.

T h i s i s n 't a n ew pr ob el m…….

Eagle138 wrote:
Possibly. I feel like in that case, click would be faster anyway, though.

Yeah, definitely. A click is way faster and more deliberate than hovering. (well, not faster than hovering, but fast enough)

Last edited by musicROCKS013 (Aug. 17, 2022 00:30:47)

Unity_and_Cq

Look, I’m going to be honest, this suggestion makes no sense. It has no purpose. You say it’s to encourage people to read the about me, they already can. You say it will decrease lag, it will cause more. You say it will help those with a lot of tabs, it doesn’t.

I don’t get why you think this would be added to basically use a click for the same purpose.

____TheAroace

Unity_and_Cq wrote:
A new problem: How many people would use this thing if it was implemented rather than just clicking the profile? A lot of users are already used to clicking the profile so adding this in would be confusing.

It's not? about 2 - 5 people have said the exact thing as you.

Unity_and_Cq

DashaTheAroace wrote:
Unity_and_Cq wrote:
A new problem: How many people would use this thing if it was implemented rather than just clicking the profile? A lot of users are already used to clicking the profile so adding this in would be confusing.
It's not? about 2 - 5 people have said the exact thing as you.

Even if it’s not new, I personally think that this should be brought up.

musicROCKS013

Unity_and_Cq wrote:
Even if it’s not new, I personally think that this should be brought up.

Maybe you missed this post, but I think we're just going to leave this specific argument unresolved and think of new things to discuss about.

____TheAroace

Okay guys this topic is turning into a debate over whether this is necessary or not. Let's not start unnecessary arguments over these things.

Unity_and_Cq

musicROCKS013 wrote:
Unity_and_Cq wrote:
Even if it’s not new, I personally think that this should be brought up.
Maybe you missed this post, but I think we're just going to leave this specific argument unresolved and think of new things to discuss about.

I did read it. I would like this argument to be resolved as it is kind of important.

DashaTheAroace wrote:
Okay guys this topic is turning into a debate over whether this is necessary or not. Let's not start unnecessary arguments over these things.

It’s not a debate.

Last edited by Unity_and_Cq (Aug. 17, 2022 00:35:18)

musicROCKS013

Unity_and_Cq wrote:
I did read it. I would like this argument to be resolved as it is kind of important.

Could we just leave it as unresolved for now? We're honestly going in circles.
-
So, would you be able to scroll with the scroll bar using the scroll wheel or do you need to drag the scroll bar to scroll? Or either?

Discuss Scratch