Tell the user when their project is marked as NFE.

thugadugary

I don't see a need for this. It could lead to negativity and drama if someone doesn't know why their project was NFE'd, and they'd think the Scratch Team was just targeting and censoring them for no reason.

It could have some uses for some users, but I'm personally not a fan.

Jackson49_test

Bump

OPagel

bump

StrongPeanut

Support

AIGamesDeveloper

StrongPeanut wrote:
Support

Please give a reason as to why you support it. Otherwise, it would be marked as “unconstructive”
Thanks!

StrongPeanut

I am more than happy to confirm, once I notice the NFE, it will be clear what I need to pay attention to the next time I create a piece of work.

thugatwoary

thugadugary wrote:
I don't see a need for this. It could lead to negativity and drama if someone doesn't know why their project was NFE'd, and they'd think the Scratch Team was just targeting and censoring them for no reason.

It could have some uses for some users, but I'm personally not a fan.

wow i was stupid back then

It would not lead to any more negativity and drama than project removals already do, and those already don't make much drama. It also really increases moderator transparency which is something this website is seriously lacking at the moment.

QuantumScratcher

Support lists are discouraged since they bring attention to supporters and and follow the infamous support convention.

SonicFanX123_321

support for obvious reasons stated in the OP

why does scratch team not tell you when you got a project marked as NFE, yet they do when it gets removed?

-Valtren-

SonicFanX123_321 wrote:
support for obvious reasons stated in the OP

why does scratch team not tell you when you got a project marked as NFE, yet they do when it gets removed?

well maybe they don't want you to know? I mean people already get mad when their project gets removed. NFE would be even worse.
besides it would be obvious since it wouldn't appear in searches and stuff

Super_Scratch_Bros20

henhenboben

bump and support

Elijah999999

Please don't list your supporters. That encourages people to just say “support!” and this is a forum, not a vote.

Knightbot63

henhenboben wrote:
(#314)
bump and support

why?

Elijah999999 wrote:
(#315)
Please don't list your supporters. That encourages people to just say “support!” and this is a forum, not a vote.

Well, I honestly don't think the owner is “active” anymore…
~~~
I give a support. But the only reason why is because so you can remove those things that got it NFE'd.

Preseves_jar

BUMP

TF3RDL

Elijah999999 wrote:
Please don't list your supporters. That encourages people to just say “support!” and this is a forum, not a vote.

This is something that I would agree with since

if <post is just [support or no support and with no explanation why v]> then // not a blockspam, it is just a weird format that is hard to read
 say [it is more like a useless junk, but technically not a spam]
end

Anyways, support because it would be helpful to know what's wrong with the project that led to being marked NFE like use of actual gun sounds whereas the project has nothing to do with guns, use of hacked blocks, or minor inappropriate content that aren't enough to violate Scratch Community Guidelines. However, this comes with a downside since not all users are equal, this includes but not limited to the user might leave unconstructive claims like “the ST censored my project” or something like that

PaperMarioFan2022

Bump

Whoops, wasn’t meaning to bump this topic.

I support because of OP reasons, and this could clear up a lot of confusion with projects.

Last edited by PaperMarioFan2022 (May 26, 2023 14:04:42)

chriscreators14

Support, this will be really useful

SockAlternative

-Valtren- wrote:
SonicFanX123_321 wrote:
support for obvious reasons stated in the OP

why does scratch team not tell you when you got a project marked as NFE, yet they do when it gets removed?
well maybe they don't want you to know? I mean people already get mad when their project gets removed. NFE would be even worse.
besides it would be obvious since it wouldn't appear in searches and stuff

I don't think people would be even angrier at a nfe than a removal.

DifferentDance8

Elijah999999 wrote:
Please don't list your supporters. That encourages people to just say “support!” and this is a forum, not a vote.

OP didn't list their supporters though?

Discuss Scratch