Ban "Support for reasons in Scratcher's post"

Reev0102

In the Suggestions forum, I've seen a lot of posts similar to “Support for reasons in OP” or “Support for reasons in Scratcher's post”. These posts should be banned, because they aren't adding to the discussion, and can be seen as spam.

Yellowsheep43

It's the way of showing support without restating the point

Reev0102

Yellowsheep43 wrote:
It's the way of showing support without restating the point

You should only show your support if you have something to add. Otherwise you're spamming.

Last edited by Reev0102 (Oct. 25, 2021 13:26:42)

-EmeraldThunder-

Support, it's really not constructive, this should be discouraged or banned.

Last edited by -EmeraldThunder- (Oct. 25, 2021 12:30:44)

7salad3salad

How is the Scratch Team going to crack down on this? Mute?

Queer_Royalty

I'm pretty sure they already are banned.

dertermenter

Yellowsheep43 wrote:
It's the way of showing support without restating the point

If someone has repeated your point then don’t post.
-
I agree they are unconstructive (adds nothing to conversation) but scratch hasn’t banned any unconstructive support posts yet - maybe they don’t want to.
-

Queer_Royalty wrote:
I'm pretty sure they already are banned.

They aren’t

banana439monkey

necroposting isn't “banned”, it's just against etiquette

Banana

ItsMe-XTV-

banana439monkey wrote:
necroposting isn't “banned”, it's just against etiquette

Banana

wha-
this isnt talking about necroposting

DangerousDawn

Reev0102 wrote:
Otherwise you're spamming.

May you please explain how and why YOU think this is spam?

Reev0102

DawnRooney27 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
Otherwise you're spamming.
May you please explain how and why YOU think this is spam?

“Support for reasons in Scratcher's post” isn't adding to the discussion and isn't helping anyone; therefore, it's spamming.

vudeptrai090211

Reev0102 wrote:
DawnRooney27 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
Otherwise you're spamming.
May you please explain how and why YOU think this is spam?
“Support for reasons in Scratcher's post” isn't adding to the discussion and isn't helping anyone; therefore, it's spamming.

Hmmm…But what will we do if we agree the scratchers' opinion (but we cant repeat their reasons)? Don't say anything?

Last edited by vudeptrai090211 (Oct. 25, 2021 13:54:47)

DangerousDawn

Reev0102 wrote:
DawnRooney27 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
Otherwise you're spamming.
May you please explain how and why YOU think this is spam?
“Support for reasons in Scratcher's post” isn't adding to the discussion and isn't helping anyone; therefore, it's spamming.

But it is just stating that you support for reason stated in another post. Spam is just saying like,

User wrote:
support

It would be helpful to quote the exact reasons if you aren't going to type it out. But other than that, No Support.

vudeptrai090211

DawnRooney27 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
DawnRooney27 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
Otherwise you're spamming.
May you please explain how and why YOU think this is spam?
“Support for reasons in Scratcher's post” isn't adding to the discussion and isn't helping anyone; therefore, it's spamming.
It would be helpful to quote the exact reasons if you aren't going to type it out. But other than that, No Support.

I agree. No support. If we repeat their reasons, isn't it a spam?. Aditionally, we are not allowed to say “support” or no?

Last edited by vudeptrai090211 (Oct. 25, 2021 14:04:02)

Reev0102

vudeptrai090211 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
DawnRooney27 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
Otherwise you're spamming.
May you please explain how and why YOU think this is spam?
“Support for reasons in Scratcher's post” isn't adding to the discussion and isn't helping anyone; therefore, it's spamming.
Hmmm…But what will we do if we agree the scratchers' opinion (but we cant repeat their reasons)? Don't say anything?

Yeah, don't say anything.

DawnRooney27 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
DawnRooney27 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
Otherwise you're spamming.
May you please explain how and why YOU think this is spam?
“Support for reasons in Scratcher's post” isn't adding to the discussion and isn't helping anyone; therefore, it's spamming.
But it is just stating that you support for reason stated in another post. Spam is just saying like,
User wrote:
support
It would be helpful to quote the exact reasons if you aren't going to type it out. But other than that, No Support.

But why post if you don't have anything to add?

vudeptrai090211

Reev0102 wrote:
But why post if you don't have anything to add?

“I think that is cool. The reason is it will make me easier to use. So, yeah, support” No, no, that is spam :(
DUDE, ARE YOU SERIOUS? SO I CANNOT SAY I SUPPORT OR NOT??? THAT MEANS YOU CANNOT SAY YOUR OPINION!!!

Last edited by vudeptrai090211 (Oct. 25, 2021 14:27:32)

TurtleLegos

vudeptrai090211 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
DawnRooney27 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
Otherwise you're spamming.
May you please explain how and why YOU think this is spam?
“Support for reasons in Scratcher's post” isn't adding to the discussion and isn't helping anyone; therefore, it's spamming.
Hmmm…But what will we do if we agree the scratchers' opinion (but we cant repeat their reasons)? Don't say anything?

Correct

Reev0102

vudeptrai090211 wrote:
Reev0102 wrote:
But why post if you don't have anything to add?
“I think that is cool. The reason is it will make me easier to use. So, yeah, support” No, no, that is spam :(
DUDE, ARE YOU SERIOUS? SO I CANNOT SAY I SUPPORT OR NOT??? THAT MEANS YOU CANNOT SAY YOUR OPINION!!!

If you have anything to say (related to the topic) that someone else hasn't said already, go ahead and post.

Yellowsheep43

If people say the same reason for supporting, it's eventually gonna become spam.
Although it may seem spam, it's better to say “Support for the reasons above”

vudeptrai090211

Yellowsheep43 wrote:
If people say the same reason for supporting, it's eventually gonna become spam.
Although it may seem spam, it's better to say “Support for the reasons above”

true

Discuss Scratch