ScratchCatHELLO wrote:

the scratch team already implemented the reply limit

I manged to make more than 26 replies here.

Chiroyce wrote:

ScratchCatHELLO wrote:

the scratch team already implemented the reply limit

I manged to make more than 26 replies here.

Chiroyce oh chiroyce. Studios aren’t 3.0 yet, that means the reply limit hasn’t been added yet. Sorry @ScratchCatHELLO. That isn’t true yet.

PoIygon wrote:

Chiroyce oh chiroyce. Studios aren’t 3.0 yet, that means the reply limit hasn’t been added yet. Sorry @ScratchCatHELLO. That isn’t true yet.

PoIygon oh poIygon. Thanks for confirming that. Sorry @ScratchCatHELLO. That may only be implemented by mid June.

Ok so I am sorta confused - but I don't agree with the 25 reply limit, as what about SWC, SAC, SPC and many other awesome campers?

if the 25 reply limit is added what about the reply chains that have 25+ replys?

yumyumsushi_ wrote:

if the 25 reply limit is added what about the reply chains that have 25+ replys?

either they might get deleted very unlikely or just you cant reply to them so basically comment rps are gone unless people do it in a project but projects can handle more than 25 replies so why can studios only hold 25 replies?

D:<

JoyfuII wrote:

D:<

Please be constructive on the forums.

Blazewing202 wrote:

Hello… I have ran a roleplay here for a year, and it has been the highlight of my time on Scratch, and I know everyone else loves roleplaying here too. The roleplays and fun will be destroyed if Scratch Team bans over 25 limit of comments. I would be horrified if my roleplay (which has run for over a year and is very active) gets destroyed in the process. I have met many of my closest Scratch friends through rolaplays, and they have improved me and helped my social skills a lot. They have always been there for me, and it would hurt me deeply to know that the next generation of Scratchers cannot experience what I have through roleplays. I know many others who would agree with me. Please don't set a limit on comments. I know I am only one person saying this, but I know hundreds of other people who agree with me on this. I beg you not to limit the comments. Thank you for taking your time to read this, and I hope you all have a wonderful day.

They currently are setting the limit, and it is planned to be implemented around mid-June. And yes, unfortunately, roleplaying is one of the many things that will be harmed by this if not reverted.

rainliqht- wrote:

Ok so I am sorta confused - but I don't agree with the 25 reply limit, as what about SWC, SAC, SPC and many other awesome campers?

Basically, all of the technical stuff here just says that this idea, to improve the comment APIs themselves rather than limit to 25 replies, would fix the same issues the Scratch Team is trying to fix with this limit. And yes, unfortunately, all of the camps would likely be harmed by this. Luckily, for SWC, we do have a few backup plans, but we are unsure how we would maintain this in the long run, unfortunately…

Hey everyone! There were a variety of reasons why this limit was created. In the coming weeks, the Scratch Team will share a forum post with more information about the reasons behind this change. We're also discussing better ways to gather feedback from Scratchers in the future. There is some speculating going on in this thread which isn't very productive, so we're going to close it for now. We welcome your feedback in the future and look forward to sharing more with you.