Discuss Scratch

Ian-Stewart
Scratcher
500+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

What would be really nice is a custom URL for your projects. For example, you could have a project called Dodge the Ball. So you could make the URL like this: “scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball”. I already use a custom URL for YouTube, so why not make it available on Scratch?

Please reply and thanks for reading!
Botcho_Otkho
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

I'm not sure how would this be helpful… would you give me an explanation?
Ian-Stewart
Scratcher
500+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

Botcho_Otkho wrote:

I'm not sure how would this be helpful… would you give me an explanation?
So you know how project URLs have a bunch of numbers in it? They could make it easier by making your own. Imagine you had a game called “Car Racing”. Instead of a complicated URL, you could just type in “scratch.mit.edu/car-racing”. Or whatever other custom name you want to use. But unfortunately you can't do that yet.
Hope this helped.
Vibrato
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

There are hundreds of ‘Car Racing’ projects. How would that work?
Ian-Stewart
Scratcher
500+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

Vibrato wrote:

There are hundreds of ‘Car Racing’ projects. How would that work?
It's just an example. I understand, I just had to think of something quickly.
EZ-Games
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
Vibrato
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

EZ-Games wrote:

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
But still would be a problem because a user can name two projects the same thing like if shalebridge accidentally named one of their projects the same as the one from the day before.
EZ-Games
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

Vibrato wrote:

EZ-Games wrote:

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
But still would be a problem because a user can name two projects the same thing like if shalebridge accidentally named one of their projects the same as the one from the day before.

That makes sense, so yeah, I don't think the custom URL will work, unfortunately.

Last edited by EZ-Games (July 16, 2019 20:25:59)

Ian-Stewart
Scratcher
500+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

EZ-Games wrote:

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
Wow, nice idea! I didn't even think of this!
Ian-Stewart
Scratcher
500+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

EZ-Games wrote:

Vibrato wrote:

EZ-Games wrote:

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
But still would be a problem because a user can name two projects the same thing like if shalebridge accidentally named one of their projects the same as the one from the day before.

That makes sense, so yeah, I don't think the custom URL will work, unfortunately.
Yeah, I understand, but they're better than that. They'll probably notify the user that the name was already used.
EZ-Games
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

Ian-Stewart wrote:

EZ-Games wrote:

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
Wow, nice idea! I didn't even think of this!

Thank you!
300th post, let's goooo!

Last edited by EZ-Games (July 16, 2019 21:42:37)

Wahsp
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

Vibrato wrote:

EZ-Games wrote:

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
But still would be a problem because a user can name two projects the same thing like if shalebridge accidentally named one of their projects the same as the one from the day before.
Pretty sure you can't name your project the same thing as another project you have, it adds a -2 or something like that to the title. So it could work
Ian-Stewart
Scratcher
500+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

Wahsp wrote:

Vibrato wrote:

EZ-Games wrote:

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
But still would be a problem because a user can name two projects the same thing like if shalebridge accidentally named one of their projects the same as the one from the day before.
Pretty sure you can't name your project the same thing as another project you have, it adds a -2 or something like that to the title. So it could work
Good point! If this feature was added, finding projects would also be a lot easier.
Vibrato
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

Wahsp wrote:

Vibrato wrote:

EZ-Games wrote:

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
But still would be a problem because a user can name two projects the same thing like if shalebridge accidentally named one of their projects the same as the one from the day before.
Pretty sure you can't name your project the same thing as another project you have, it adds a -2 or something like that to the title. So it could work
No, you can name 2 projects the same thing, just tried.
Ian-Stewart
Scratcher
500+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

Vibrato wrote:

Wahsp wrote:

Vibrato wrote:

EZ-Games wrote:

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
But still would be a problem because a user can name two projects the same thing like if shalebridge accidentally named one of their projects the same as the one from the day before.
Pretty sure you can't name your project the same thing as another project you have, it adds a -2 or something like that to the title. So it could work
No, you can name 2 projects the same thing, just tried.
Oh, okay. But if they added the custom URL feature, it would probably notify the user that they've already used that name, if they knew that kind of thing would happen.
Vibrato
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

Ian-Stewart wrote:

Vibrato wrote:

Wahsp wrote:

Vibrato wrote:

EZ-Games wrote:

I guess this could work, the only problem is that if your project was named Dodge The Ball, and this ended up being the URL: scratch.mit.edu/dodge-the-ball, there could be a lot of projects that have that name, and then have the same URL, so, maybe it could be like this instead: scratch.mit.edu/*username here*/dodge-the-ball, so that would fix the problem with having the same URL as other Scratcher's projects, if this makes sense.
But still would be a problem because a user can name two projects the same thing like if shalebridge accidentally named one of their projects the same as the one from the day before.
Pretty sure you can't name your project the same thing as another project you have, it adds a -2 or something like that to the title. So it could work
No, you can name 2 projects the same thing, just tried.
Oh, okay. But if they added the custom URL feature, it would probably notify the user that they've already used that name, if they knew that kind of thing would happen.
Oof nevermind when I moved it to trash it added an awkward -2
StrangeMagic32
Scratcher
1000+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

what about you can only have so many custom urls per person (10 maybe) and you can enable or disable custom urls on projects
Ian-Stewart
Scratcher
500+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

StrangeMagic32 wrote:

what about you can only have so many custom urls per person (10 maybe) and you can enable or disable custom urls on projects
Yeah, it would probably take up less data if there was a custom URL limit, meaning that there would be more available custom names.
Ian-Stewart
Scratcher
500+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

Anybody with suggestions, please reply

Last edited by Ian-Stewart (July 17, 2019 14:27:01)

Ian-Stewart
Scratcher
500+ posts

Make a Custom URL!

S U P P O R T

Last edited by Ian-Stewart (July 16, 2019 23:18:16)

Powered by DjangoBB