Rethink account blocks/bans/suspensions.

Inkulumo

Yeah, but people would still want access to their accounts and projects, which you can't do logged out.

myeducate

You missed the whole point! Please READ the post

GamesGuyTV

Why don't we make projects that you share must be approved by the moderator before it can be shared

cul8er

GamesGuyTV wrote:
Why don't we make projects that you share must be approved by the moderator before it can be shared

I think that would take up too much of their time.

I'm leaning towards a no support on this one. It all boils down to what a ban is - a punishment or a preventative method. I'm sympathetic to both sides of the argument, but I think MonsterOfTheDeep's quoting of cheddargirl makes the most sense.

Inkulumo

@myeducate I was talking to mathlycat.

myeducate

Inkulumo wrote:
@myeducate I was talking to mathlycat.

Click “Quote”.

YubNubEwok

GamesGuyTV wrote:
Why don't we make projects that you share must be approved by the moderator before it can be shared

I highly doubt a moderator has time for that…

myeducate

YubNubEwok wrote:
GamesGuyTV wrote:
Why don't we make projects that you share must be approved by the moderator before it can be shared
I highly doubt a moderator has time for that…

I agree. It's never been like that so why now?

TK421bsod

Support.

YubNubEwok

TK421bsod wrote:
Support.

Why do you support?

Haz-_-

ѕυpporт! ιт woυld вe good ғor вanned people тo geт тнere projecтѕ вacĸ wιтнoυт мaĸιng ιт over agaιn (мy ғrιend ιѕ ғrυѕтraтed вecaυѕe нe dιdn'т wanт тo мaĸe тнe projecтѕ agaιn)!

asqwde

Support!

YubNubEwok

asqwde wrote:
Support!

Why do you support?

Botcho_Otkho

removed

Last edited by Botcho_Otkho (April 11, 2020 10:02:54)

myeducate

Bump

hellounicorns2

Yes, support! While I have never had a mute/ban, I have seen many scratchers who have when close to finishing important projects. It is important to note that IP address bans aren’t really the last resort, they are just used when scratchers look like they will sock puppet (I would add a scratch wiki link, but I don’t have the time)

Nero-Guineadoq

I don't support this, because the whole point of being banned is losing the privilege of using the Scratch website in any way, including making & editing projects

myeducate

Nero-Guineadoq wrote:
I don't support this, because the whole point of being banned is losing the privilege of using the Scratch website in any way, including making & editing projects

Please read the post “before you say no support”

Haz-_-

Nero-Guineadoq wrote:
I don't support this, because the whole point of being banned is losing the privilege of using the Scratch website in any way, including making & editing projects

So? would you be sad when your account was blocked; and you couldn't view/download projects that could have taken 2 months or something?

Nero-Guineadoq

Haz-_- wrote:
Nero-Guineadoq wrote:
I don't support this, because the whole point of being banned is losing the privilege of using the Scratch website in any way, including making & editing projects
So? would you be sad when your account was blocked; and you couldn't view/download projects that could have taken 2 months or something?

I just wouldn't do anything to get blocked for

Discuss Scratch