Discuss Scratch
- kittycat841
-
100+ posts
Epilepsy warning
So, if you look around here on Scratch, you might find some scratch projects with a sprite with this script:
It might not have an epilepsy warning. If someone with epilepsy saw one of those projects, and it didn't have an epilepsy warning, someone could have a seizure.
That's why I'm proposing this idea for an epilepsy warning.
If your project contains flashing lights or fast-moving images, you can check this box that says:
This is effective because some scratchers don't look at the notes and credits or instructions and it might look unprofessional if you have “EPILEPSY WARNING” in your title. Red is a bright and warning color, so people would notice it if they are sensitive to flashing lights or fast moving images.
Thoughts?
forever
change [color v] effect by (50)
end
It might not have an epilepsy warning. If someone with epilepsy saw one of those projects, and it didn't have an epilepsy warning, someone could have a seizure.
That's why I'm proposing this idea for an epilepsy warning.
If your project contains flashing lights or fast-moving images, you can check this box that says:
My project contains flashing lights and/or fast moving imagesThere. Simple, and effective. If the Scratcher checked the box, a message similar to the username block warning but in red would say:
Epilepsy Warning: This project contains fast moving pictures and/or fast moving images
This is effective because some scratchers don't look at the notes and credits or instructions and it might look unprofessional if you have “EPILEPSY WARNING” in your title. Red is a bright and warning color, so people would notice it if they are sensitive to flashing lights or fast moving images.
Thoughts?
- Fupicat
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
I actually think these projects should be discouraged or reported. An epilepsy warning option might encourage people to create projects like that, which I don't think is a good idea.
- LionHeart70
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
Support, but I don't think anyone with epilepsy will be on the internet since photosensitive epilepsy can be triggered by things like television, fluorescent lights, even a normal project. So I do assume that they'll just stay off the internet generally, but I do guess that there might be some people with epilepsy that only have seizures from flashy images.
However, some people that DON'T have epilepsy might not like flashing lights either, some people (like me) might just get eyestrain or a headache or something like that.
But generally, support.
However, some people that DON'T have epilepsy might not like flashing lights either, some people (like me) might just get eyestrain or a headache or something like that.
But generally, support.
- aking_
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
^^ Support, but I don't think anyone with epilepsy will be on the internet since photosensitive epilepsy can be triggered by things like television, fluorescent lights, even a normal project.
Still support this though!
- DownsGameClub
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
I have a similar message in one of my projects stuck in the instructions box. Wouldn't this be enough?
- walkcycle
-
500+ posts
Epilepsy warning
I know some Scratchers add an epilepsy warning to their project, but I haven't heard of an actual episode of the medical condition by a Scratcher viewing one.
- aking_
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
Yeah, but better safe than sorry I know some Scratchers add an epilepsy warning to their project, but I haven't heard of an actual episode of the medical condition by a Scratcher viewing one.
- LionHeart70
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
I mean, that's true and all, but it is a good idea to keep in mind what I said in my post; I know some Scratchers add an epilepsy warning to their project, but I haven't heard of an actual episode of the medical condition by a Scratcher viewing one.
but I do guess that there might be some people with epilepsy that only have seizures from flashy images.
- walkcycle
-
500+ posts
Epilepsy warning
I mean, that's true and all, but it is a good idea to keep in mind what I said in my post;but I do guess that there might be some people with epilepsy that only have seizures from flashy images.
yeah, but this part of your comment
but I don't think anyone with epilepsy will be on the internet since photosensitive epilepsy can be triggered by things like television, fluorescent lights, even a normal project. So I do assume that they'll just stay off the internet generally,
also, it does not seem like a problem that warning messages could help with, or i would expect them on sites like YouTube. this may be because the set of conditions prone to triggering varies from individual to individual. we would just be guessing that a project could trigger it.
- FancyFoxy
-
500+ posts
Epilepsy warning
But how can the system detect if a project has stuff that can cause epilepsy?
EDIT: I'm always telling people to read the OP, but I didn't do so here. xD
EDIT: I'm always telling people to read the OP, but I didn't do so here. xD
Last edited by FancyFoxy (Aug. 14, 2017 23:51:03)
- kittycat841
-
100+ posts
Epilepsy warning
But how can the system detect if a project has stuff that can cause epilepsy?
It wouldn't. Scratchers would check a box saying that their project should have the epilepsy warning. If they forgot, others can report it so it has the epilepsy warning.
- LionHeart70
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
If you didn't read the entire OP, it'd be a checkbox thing. But how can the system detect if a project has stuff that can cause epilepsy?
- FancyFoxy
-
500+ posts
Epilepsy warning
Whoops.If you didn't read the entire OP, it'd be a checkbox thing. But how can the system detect if a project has stuff that can cause epilepsy?
- PrincessPanda_test_
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
I believe just putting an epilepsy warning in the notes and credits would do the same.
- adriel001
-
100+ posts
Epilepsy warning
the report button is better and more useful So, if you look around here on Scratch, you might find some scratch projects with a sprite with this script:forever
change [color v] effect by (50)
end
It might not have an epilepsy warning. If someone with epilepsy saw one of those projects, and it didn't have an epilepsy warning, someone could have a seizure.
That's why I'm proposing this idea for an epilepsy warning.
If your project contains flashing lights or fast-moving images, you can check this box that says:My project contains flashing lights and/or fast moving imagesThere. Simple, and effective. If the Scratcher checked the box, a message similar to the username block warning but in red would say:Epilepsy Warning: This project contains fast moving pictures and/or fast moving images
This is effective because some scratchers don't look at the notes and credits or instructions and it might look unprofessional if you have “EPILEPSY WARNING” in your title. Red is a bright and warning color, so people would notice it if they are sensitive to flashing lights or fast moving images.
Thoughts?
- Wahsp
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
I agree. Scratchers might want to ‘test it out’ without good intent. I think a simple warning with the instructions of the project would be okay I actually think these projects should be discouraged or reported. An epilepsy warning option might encourage people to create projects like that, which I don't think is a good idea.
- TheAdriCoolManDude
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
Shouldn't they be reported if they are giving people siezures?
- Sheep_maker
-
1000+ posts
Epilepsy warning
Yes, but it's best to prevent it before it happens. Shouldn't they be reported if they are giving people siezures?