I've been on and off scratch a few time and in general always joined a collaboration or two for fun and while most of the team was dedicated the collaboration always fell through whether it was Cookie Clicker, Star Wars the Untold Stories, or even Google in Scratch. They never worked out. So my question is, has a collab ever come out with a finished project?

yeah

They have - in many cases they don't, but sometimes they do.

Many of them do work out! In fact, A few have been on the front page!
(But I get what you mean)

doodlebob2 wrote:

I've been on and off scratch a few time and in general always joined a collaboration or two for fun and while most of the team was dedicated the collaboration always fell through whether it was Cookie Clicker, Star Wars the Untold Stories, or even Google in Scratch. They never worked out. So my question is, has a collab ever come out with a finished project?

The more people there are in a collab, then the greater the chance that it will fail. A collab of just two people is almost always successful. A collab of 20 people will have at least one, and probably more, people who don't carry their share of the load and have to be replaced.

footsocktoe wrote:

doodlebob2 wrote:

I've been on and off scratch a few time and in general always joined a collaboration or two for fun and while most of the team was dedicated the collaboration always fell through whether it was Cookie Clicker, Star Wars the Untold Stories, or even Google in Scratch. They never worked out. So my question is, has a collab ever come out with a finished project?

The more people there are in a collab, then the greater the chance that it will fail. A collab of just two people is almost always successful. A collab of 20 people will have at least one, and probably more, people who don't carry their share of the load and have to be replaced.

Yeah, I have found that with many colab's

Some collabs work, others don't. sometimes it depends on what happens in the collab, or people aren't working on it.
It varies.

There's a featured “Waving Through A Window” collab right now.

I am Closing this Post