Change project links

banana439monkey

What I have seen throughout the community is Scratchers getting muted because they've tried to post project links and the filterbot thinks the ID's a phone number. This idea could mean changing the project IDs to something else. You can't have two projects with exactly the same name on one account. This is the idea: having links not to go to something like https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/projects/104 - instead, https://scratch-mit-edu.ezproxyberklee.flo.org/projects/andresmh/Weekend - this idea could help many people like you and I.

Banana

Mrcomputer1

Semi Support
Keep the old links but allow the user to set a custom link for the project
EDIT: Custom link example: scratch.mit.edu/p/(custom link) or /p/(user)/(custom link)
EDIT 2: Also allow for studios and users (/s/(custom link) and /u/(custom link))
EDIT 3: Allow the user to change the custom link whenever they want

Last edited by Mrcomputer1 (May 30, 2016 09:11:03)

awesome-llama

Mrcomputer1 wrote:
Semi Support
Keep the old links but allow the user to set a custom link for the project

That ^

banana439monkey

Mrcomputer1 wrote:
Semi Support
Keep the old links but allow the user to set a custom link for the project
EDIT: Custom link example: scratch.mit.edu/p/(custom link) or /p/(user)/(custom link)
EDIT 2: Also allow for studios and users (/s/(custom link) and /u/(custom link))
EDIT 3: Allow the user to change the custom link whenever they want

Yes, it would make the ST's job harder if they were to change every project link

Banana

EDIT: Not custom link.

Last edited by banana439monkey (May 31, 2016 07:21:27)

-raspberry_

What if the user had 2 projects with the same name?
So, No Support

Sheep_maker

JakeCarroll wrote:
What if the user had 2 projects with the same name?
So, No Support

Don't no support based off the lack of knowledge.

Oh! Not to mention you can't have two projects with the same name. It automatically adds something like a -1 to the name (that's where Untitled-2 comes from)

bigpuppy

awesome-llama wrote:
Mrcomputer1 wrote:
Semi Support
Keep the old links but allow the user to set a custom link for the project
That ^

banana439monkey

JakeCarroll wrote:
What if the user had 2 projects with the same name?
So, No Support

you can't have that. say I had a project called “hi” - if I made another project called “hi”, it would turn into “hi-2” in reality.

Banana

EDIT: #ninja'd by sheep_maker - whoops. xD

EDIT 2: Also, if there were two projects with the same name on the same profile, I wouldn't be suggesting this

Last edited by banana439monkey (May 31, 2016 08:43:55)

Sigton

Semi support. I can see why it could be useful but I'm not sure it's worth the ST's time.

Sigton

banana439monkey

Sigton wrote:
Semi support. I can see why it could be useful but I'm not sure it's worth the ST's time.

Sigton

I did say something on #4.

Banana

_Comicfan_

JakeCarroll wrote:
What if the user had 2 projects with the same name?
So, No Support

That's what Untitled-2 is for. Also, semi-support. This would be a nice feature, but I'm not sure it's worth the ST's time, as Sigton said.

banana439monkey

_Comicfan_ wrote:
JakeCarroll wrote:
What if the user had 2 projects with the same name?
So, No Support
That's what Untitled-2 is for. Also, semi-support. This would be a nice feature, but I'm not sure it's worth the ST's time, as Sigton said.

as per #4

Banana

_Comicfan_

banana439monkey wrote:
_Comicfan_ wrote:
JakeCarroll wrote:
What if the user had 2 projects with the same name?
So, No Support
That's what Untitled-2 is for. Also, semi-support. This would be a nice feature, but I'm not sure it's worth the ST's time, as Sigton said.
as per #4

Banana

Oh, didn't see that. Support.

banana439monkey

_Comicfan_ wrote:
banana439monkey wrote:
_Comicfan_ wrote:
JakeCarroll wrote:
What if the user had 2 projects with the same name?
So, No Support
That's what Untitled-2 is for. Also, semi-support. This would be a nice feature, but I'm not sure it's worth the ST's time, as Sigton said.
as per #4

Banana
Oh, didn't see that. Support.

Banana

_Comicfan_

banana439monkey wrote:
_Comicfan_ wrote:
banana439monkey wrote:
_Comicfan_ wrote:
JakeCarroll wrote:
What if the user had 2 projects with the same name?
So, No Support
That's what Untitled-2 is for. Also, semi-support. This would be a nice feature, but I'm not sure it's worth the ST's time, as Sigton said.
as per #4

Banana
Oh, didn't see that. Support.

Banana

Comic

PrincessPanda_test_

Mrcomputer1 wrote:
Semi Support
Keep the old links but allow the user to set a custom link for the project
EDIT: Custom link example: scratch.mit.edu/p/(custom link) or /p/(user)/(custom link)
EDIT 2: Also allow for studios and users (/s/(custom link) and /u/(custom link))
EDIT 3: Allow the user to change the custom link whenever they want

Sigton

banana439monkey wrote:
I did say something on #4.

Banana

I shall elaborate.
I wasn't meaning to change all the existing links, I was referring to the task of implementing the feature for custom links (which also may be hard to moderate).

Sigton

banana439monkey

Sigton wrote:
banana439monkey wrote:
I did say something on #4.

Banana
I shall elaborate.
I wasn't meaning to change all the existing links, I was referring to the task of implementing the feature for custom links (which also may be hard to moderate).

Sigton

Custom links are worse than my original proposal

Banana

Sigton

banana439monkey wrote:
Custom links are worse than my original proposal

Banana

But that would require a major changeso the architecture of the website.

Sigton

banana439monkey

Sigton wrote:
banana439monkey wrote:
Custom links are worse than my original proposal

Banana
But that would require a major changeso the architecture of the website.

Sigton

Or are you thinking about the username changing thing?

Banana

Discuss Scratch